Q: Left front strut makes clanking sound when driving over bumps

asked by on July 25, 2016

I had told the dealership that I could leave my car for only one day, but they kept it for a week and refused to let me take it. They said they wanted to paint it when I told them not to. I asked, but they avoided telling me where they were painting it. When I did finally get it back, 56 miles had been driven on it. All my radio stations had been changed and it had a very low MPG. So they had been driving around in ‘my’ car!!

It has a loose lining panel in the area where the left rear strut is and the strut clanks when I drive over bumps. When I returned my car, the dealer ‘did’ hear the clunk noise and said it was the brake. When I went back to pick up my car, they said they had ordered the wrong brake and laughed! I called them two weeks later and they said it would be in the next day and laughed again. They did install the brake, but the clunking noise is still there. I proceeded to go to two other dealerships for 2nd/3rd opinions but neither of them could hear the noise. So I put an action cam in my car and made a video from inside the suspension. After “eight” service calls, finally they replaced the strut and fixed the clunk. But I have additional problems like the sagging to the driver’s side, a super high frame in front and several others. My question is: am I not communicating with these mechanics and can you make suggestions so I will be treated better when I go to have more problems fixed?

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

What does it mean when the Charging System light comes on in the dash?
Your dash is information central – gauges and warning lights provide you with a great deal of important information. If your Charging System light comes on (it looks like a little battery), it means there’s something wrong. It should come...
Truck idling higher than normal.
I would recommend taking the vehicle back to the facility that replaced your TPS and ensure that the throttle body gasket was replaced as well. If the gasket was not replaced a vacuum leak may exist near your throttle body...
Driver's side window not working.
The power window motor, switch or regulator may be at fault here. The most common issue is the motor failure. The door panel will have to be removed and the motor and switch tested by a qualified mechanic. Once the...
Car not starting after starter replacement
There are multiple issues that can cause a no start. When dealing with a situation the next best step would be to have a qualified technician perform a starting/charging system inspection (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/car-is-not-starting-inspection) to check the battery and starter for proper...
My engine backfires like a lean carburetor
Hello. If your engine is backfiring (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/engine-is-backfiring-inspection) and you smell gasoline then it is likely that your vehicle is running rich. Backfires can be caused by both rich and lean conditions, however a fuel smell is usually associated with a...
About the governor in engine
Hi there. Governors in a fuel system are basically a three-way valve. There is a supply port, exit port, and a dump port. As the fuel pressure regulator (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/fuel-pressure-regulator-replacement) is set the fuel pressure will remain the same as when...
My harmonic balancer is slipping
The Harmonic balancer has a steel center hub and outer ring that are bonded to a rubber ring that separates them. When the car is very old, the adhesive in the balancer dries up and the outer ring might start...
No power to the MAP sensor and getting a code P0107.
Hi there. Trace the wires to the bulk wiring harness and check continuity from the wire to the end of the plug. If there is resistance, then disconnect the battery and remove the wiring harness from the computer and check...
Engine stalls and vdc and skip lights come on
Hello. The VDC and SLIP messages come on when the computer detects an issue with the vehicle's traction control system. The most common causes for this are a faulty ABS wheel speed sensor, or some sort of electrical fault within...

Related articles

Can I Safely Add Camber to My Wheels?
It’s It’s increasingly common to see “tuner” cars (or less commonly, pickup trucks) with extreme camber settings — in other words, with wheels and tires that are noticeably tilted relative to vertical. Some owners may wonder whether changing their camber...
How Often Should Brake Fluid Be Changed?
Brake Brake fluid is a hydraulic fluid that is used in automotive braking systems. The most often used brake fluids on the market today are glycol-ether based. However, mineral oil based brake fluid is available as well. The brake fluids...
Should You Buy a Dash Cam?
If If you’re someone who loves to watch viral videos on social media, you’re going to be familiar with dash cam videos. You know the ones - car crashes caught on camera through the windshield of a car, massive explosions...