Q: Engine in bad condition

asked by on July 22, 2016

My friend owns a 2008 Scion xD 1.8L with 78K miles on it. Her battery light came on and the car broke down. The water pump bearing failed knocked off the serpentine belt - no water pump or alternator. The oil and temperature lights came on before the car died.

A local repair shop fixed water pump. She thought maybe the aftermarket security system caused the car to break down. The engine turned, but wouldn't catch and starter was ok, fuel was OK, but bad spark due to wigged out coil. The coil was replaced but it didn't help. So the repair shop found that the engine was getting really bad compression - 50 psi instead of > 100 psi - thought it might be valve timing. They also found that the oil had not been changed for many years. I was like molasses sludge. So the oil got changed. They ran individual cylinder tests and found the head gasket was bad. They found that cylinder 1 leaks to coolant passages and over to cylinder 3. The technician is concerned parts were damaged from overheating. She had a transmission service done because the fluid was really dirty, but the technician was very concerned that there's some chance they might find that the lack of maintenance plus possible overheating has caused allot of damage. What are you ideas and thoughts on this car? Thanks.

75 Point Safety Inspection Get a Quote

Yes, unfortunately if the oil had not been changed for many years this coupled with the overheating could have caused serious damage to the engine. 50 psi compression is a bad sign, this indicates massive blow-by in the combustion chambers and if it is a consistent reading across all cylinders, then it is likely this engine is in need of replacement or a major overhaul.

However, I am concerned how the oil condition and blown head gasket were overlooked and an ignition coil was replaced for a no start issue when there should been signs of mechanical engine issues while the vehicle was being cranked for the no start condition. Before going through with either a rebuild or replacement engine, you may want to get an opinion from a second mechanic and then shop around for a rebuilt or replacement engine and installation.

Based on the description here, it may not be the best course of action to rebuild this particular engine but it would be a good idea to get a second set of eyes to do a complete inspection on this before determining the best course of action.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

My Check Engine Light is on and my car barely wants to go.

When the code P0700 is set in the Powertrain Computer, it means that the Powertrain Computer or PCM is seeing greater than a specified RPM difference between the rotational speed of the Input RPM Sensor and the Transmission Output RPM...

Van will not start randomly

Hello. If you have a new battery and new terminal connectors, then I would be curious about the starter solenoid. That could cause temperamental starting with a perfectly good battery and electrical system. If the starter solenoid is beginning to...

Transmission shifting

The transmission control module has various sensors such as vehicle speed sensors, wheel speed sensors, throttle position sensors, turbine speed sensor, and transmission fluid temperature sensors that all direct information to it in order for it to perform it’s function....

Transmission in and out of overdrive

Hi and thanks for your question. The cruise control is set with the engine speed and transmission gear selection. Check the fuse to the cruise control to see if it is blown. There could be two things going on. The...

Battery died

Hello! A battery may die for a number of reasons. In old age, a battery will lose its ability to recharge, which, by definition, makes the battery bad. An alternator is part of the car's electrical system, and is built...

Oil Change issues

Hello, thank you for writing in. Your issue is likely something small and silly that you are overlooking. Often the oil filter seal sticks to the engine rather than the old oil filter when you take it off. If this...

Car leaking fluids

It sounds as though you may need a technician to come out and perform a test on the system to determine where the problem is. A mechanic from YourMechanic can come to you and check the battery, and determine why...

I want an OEM water pump used as the replacement and am willing to pay any extra cost, can I specify this as part of my appt?

Yes, you can specify only OEM parts when making your appointment. Make sure you contact customer service when making the appointment to make sure you get the requested parts you want.

Does my 2008 Kia Sedona have shocks or struts?

Your Kia has struts in the front and shocks in the back. The original equipment part numbers for the struts are 546614D101 for the right hand side and 546514D101 for the left hand side. The part number for the rear...

Related articles

How Often Should the Steering System Be Inspected?
It’s It’s usually better to fix an automotive problem early than to wait until it causes more damage or even an accident. And that general principle applies to the steering system. Luckily, periodic inspection and maintenance of the steering system...
All About Car Battery Chargers
Everyone Everyone has experienced a dead car battery from time to time. It’s common occurance, especially in winter, when batteries have to work even harder to get you to where you want to go. Fortunately, there’s a solution. A portable...
Can a Car Battery Overheat in Hot Weather?
Hot weather can cause battery fluid to evaporate and make it hard to start your car. Battery overcharging decreases the lifespan of your battery.