Q: Tranny

asked by on May 27, 2016

Hi I have a 2000 ford f250 with the 5.4L triton and an automatic transmission. My overdrive light started flashing and my check engine light came on at the same time. The truck also smells hot. But the transmission is not shifting hard or anything. Do you think there is a problem

My car has 233000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Check Engine Light is on Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote

The first thing that needs to be done is to scan the vehicle for all codes. Since the overdrive light is flashing, a simple code reader from your local parts store will not likely be of any help. Code readers are for engine related codes. They can’t access other systems like your transmission, ABS or body modules. Most of the time your check engine light will accompany a transmission code, so it is likely a transmission issue. This all means that you will need to take your truck into a repair shop that is good with electronic automotive systems, unless you have access to the needed equipment and the know-how yourself.

I have done some research on this issue and there seems to be about four scenarios that play out for this issue. Keep in mind, this is a complex problem that many technicians have been unable to diagnose and repair. With that said, there are a number of issues that create your situation.

  1. Pinched wire in steering column at the selector lever: To confirm this, the steering column covers will need to be removed and the harnesses thoroughly inspected. This is the simplest repair of the four possibilities I found.

  2. Powertrain control module (PCM) failure: If this is the case, have a veteran technician that you trust confirm this. It won’t likely be an easy diagnosis so be prepared for a significant amount of time spent to diagnose it.

  3. Ignition coils: I found several cases where ignition coils were creating electrical noise throughout the electrical system causing this issue. Ignition coils are a common problem on the 5.4L motor. Again, this should be diagnosed by an experienced technician.

  4. Wiring harness damage: There are a number of reports about wiring harness damage that can create symptoms such as this. Where they fail is not always easy to find. So this is another one that you will need an experienced technician to diagnose.

With some luck, you could have a simple shift solenoid failure. A good place to start is with a diagnosis of your check engine light by a qualified mobile technician who can come to your home or office. Consider YourMechanic.

I wish you luck.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

I crossed the lines on one of the new batteries & SPARK went the post, I screwed the pooch...

I have seen many different outcomes when it comes to hooking the battery up backwards. If you disconnected the cables as soon as you hooked them up wrong you should not need to replace the battery. Once you hook up...

Car did not engage going forward, nor in reverse

Hi we will be happy to help. The issue you are experiencing is likely due to a form of preventive maintenance that your vehicle needs. The maintenance that I'm referring to is the clutch actuator adjustment. Overtime, the clutch will...

Car vibrates and burning smell in wheel

If the brake caliper has failed, a replacement could repair the vibration issue. The most likely cause of the low speed idle is a parking brake failure, brake system issues, drive axle failure, or a bent wheel. A qualified technician,...

Key won't turn, Check Engine light on.

If it is the correct key and it is inserted all of the way in, then most likely the cylinder is bad. Wiggle the key around while trying to turn it. It may eventually unlock and turn, but this problem...

Oil pressure drops to 0 "stabilitrak" issue across message center traction control shuts off but oil sending unit was just replaced

The first thing to do is to have the Check Engine Light scanned to see what code is stored. Once this is done, then the code should be diagnosed to see if it has anything to do with the previous...

Modify 4 speed transmission to 6 speed.

Unfortunately, undertaking a procedure such as converting an existing 4 speed transmission to a 6 speed transmission would be a task that may exceed the cost of the car to undertake. As you may know, your transmission is a complex...

Drivers side power door lock actuator won't unlock

Hello. Unfortunately due to the way that this vehicle is configured the only way to get into the door when it will not open is by cutting a hole in the door panel and then replacing it after the repair....

Service Engine Soon Light came on yesterday.

While the oxygen sensor may be the cause of the service engine soon light coming on, it's best to have a certified technician correctly diagnose why the service engine light is on. When the service engine soon - or check...

Engine makes tapping noise, exhaust blows bluish smoke

If you are burning oil and you have a noise in the engine, then you need to have the noise checked to see if it is coming from a piston. You may also have valve problems and oil getting through...

Related articles

P2194 OBD-II Trouble Code: System Too Rich at Higher Load Bank 2
P2194 P2194 code definition System too rich at higher load bank 2 What the P2194 code means This trouble code indicates that the bank 2 side of the engine is receiving a higher level of fuel than was specified by...
P2192 OBD-II Trouble Code: System Too Rich at Higher Load Bank 1
P2192 P2192 code definition System Too Rich at Higher Load Bank 1 What the P2192 code means This code indicates there is a rich condition in the exhaust under high load conditions. High load conditions exist when a vehicle is...
P2251 OBD-II Trouble Code: O2 Sensor Negative Current Control Circuit/Open Bank 1 Sensor 1
P2251 P2251 code definition O2 Sensor Negative Current Control Circuit/Open Bank 1 Sensor 1 What the P2251 code means P2251 is an OBD-II generic code. The engine control module (ECM) monitors the negative current control of the O2 sensor heater...