Skip the auto shop - Our mechanics make house calls

Q: Mechanic says I need a new alternator but I don't have any problems with car starting. Should I wait until there is a problem ?

asked by on

I took my car to local oil changeplace. They noticed that my coolant hoses needed to be replaced. They couldn't fix it because they were closing in a couple of hours but they would do it next day. I went up the street to my local Dodge dealership. They said I needed new coolant hoses, an alternator, about 4 different gaskets, thermostat, new radiator hose, and serpentine belt. Total $3800! My question is do you think these things are dealership overkill? Wouldn't the STS guys have seen these things too?

My car has 174000 miles.
My car's transmission is unknown to me.

The STS mechanic may not be as qualified as a Dodge trained mechanic. I cannot be sure but most if not all oil change only places do not employ master mechanics. I can understand the reasoning for the gaskets, hoses, and belt being replaced, but the alternator would be questioned as to why it needs replaced. Sometimes when coolant gets into the alternator it can short it out. If the alternator has not gone bad yet then it could be removed and flushed with fresh water. Once it’s dried you can see if it can be salvaged. If you’d like a second opinion on this, consider YourMechanic, as a certified mechanic can diagnose your alternator and replace it as necessary.

Was this answer helpful?

Need advice from certified mechanic? Get help now!

Over 1000 mechanics are ready to answer your question.
The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details
  • Home
  • Questions
  • Mechanic says I need a new alternator but I don't have any problems with car starting. Should I wait until there is a problem ?

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

Get a quote

What others are asking

Q: truck overheating

Hi there. The problem you're describing tends to occur when one of two issues exist. First, overheating while towing can occur when air bubbles are trapped in the coolant lines. A second issue could be the coolant temperature sensor that...

Q: Truck running rough. Shaking while idling and seems to shake more when accelerating.

A faulty oxygen sensor can certainly cause an engine to run rough and cause a bit of shaking due to the imbalance in the air/fuel load. As you may know the [oxygen sensors]((https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/oxygen-sensor-replacement) which are part of your emissions system...

Q: Milky residue at the oil cap

That depends on a lot of things. If you don't drive much, especially if you are one of those people like my wife who drives 3 miles to work and 3 miles back, you can get an oily residue. ...

Related articles

How Do Power Car Windows Increase Passenger Safety?
Power windows are responsible for approximately 2,000 emergency room visits every year. When a power window closes, it exerts enough force to bruise or break bones, crush fingers, or restrict an airway. Though...
Rules of the Road For Iowa Drivers
Driving on the roads requires knowledge of the rules, many of which are based on common sense and courtesy. However, even though you know the rules in...
P2103 OBD-II Trouble Code: Throttle Actuator Control Motor Circuit High
P2103 means there is a fault with the throttle actuator control motor circuit, likely due to a defective electrical component or part.