Q: Idling while driving

asked by on August 16, 2016

I recently got some service did. The issue was that my car would idle up when I'm drive it would hesitate going up a hill. So I got it checked and they said I should replace my catalytic converter, map sensor, and thermostat and also advised on a throttle body cleaning to stop it from idling when I drive after all the service it still idles up while driving what can I do

My car has 344125 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

The main issue you have here is the number of miles on your car. With this many miles, most cars would have been completely worn out. Unless you have taken meticulous car of your car, it is often necessary to start with the obvious problems. I suspect this is what has happened here. The MAP sensor, thermostat, and a throttle body cleaning are a good beginning to fix your car, but there are bound to numerous other issues. The catalytic converter is an emissions component that in most cases won’t cause drivabilty issues.

Keep in mind, doing what they have suggested is a good beginning. Your car has a lot of miles and is likely to have several more issues. You are always entitled to a second or third opinion, but keep in mind, the shop is entitled to the time already spent on your car. If you want another opinion, I recommend having your cars driving symptoms diagnosed by a qualified technician, such as one from YourMechanic.

Good luck!

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

1988 F-150 loses power while accelerating
This is an indicator that something is wrong with the gas tank. My advice is to pull the gas tank off and have it steam cleaned. There are places that do that kind of work. When they get dirty like...
Why doesnt the truck start when changing the oil and fuel filter?
The fuel filters should of been filled before installation. You will need to bleed out all the air from the fuel system to get the vehicle to start. In the future you will need to fill filters before installation. This...
My Chevy blazer is overheating and the heater started blow cold air but now doesn't work at all what could that be?
The heater not working in some cases may be related to the overheating problem you are also having. This may be due to a faulty heater blower motor or potentially a bad heater core (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/heater-is-not-working-inspection). As you may know, the...
Replace Brake Pads with Brake Rotors?
It is recommended t replace pads with the new rotors. The old rotors would of put grooves in the pads and caused them to not be flat anymore. If you decide to use the existing pads then you should sand...
Door ajar light stuck on
Hello there, a variety of faults will cause your 2006 Scion xB to have the door ajar light on at all times. The likely faults would be a failing door switch, shorted wire, or a damaged wiring harness. If the...
Hissing sound from exhaust area?
There are a number of things this could relate to however depending on specifically where the noise is coming from may indicate different issues. Typically, a hissing sound coming from the exhaust (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/noise-from-engine-or-exhaust-inspection) may indicate a potential coolant leak, resulting...
I have a 94 buick lesabre and the engine has a slight knock and it has white smoke coming out of engine also disconnected pos and.
You should never disconnect the battery while running or it can spike the computer and alternator and damage them. The white smoke is coolant getting into engine from a leaking intake manifold or head gasket leaking. Check upper intake seals...
I am upgrading the suspension on my 2009 dodge charger sxt do I need to upgrade the rack and pinion as well
Hi Natasha. Thanks for contacting us tonight. Anytime you make an aftermarket adjustment to suspension, you should always make corresponding changes to the steering system as well - as they work together and both impact suspension alignment. It's best to...
I can hear the motor for my windshield wipers when i turn them on but they only move about an inch then completely stop
It could be that the wiper arms are loose on the shaft. It happens a lot if you have turned on your wipers when there is ice or snow on the windshield. If you grab a wiper and can move...

Related articles

How a Car's Heating System Works
The The sun sets, and the air has a chill. You pause to flip your jacket collar up, and you walk briskly to your car door and slide into the driver's seat. Once you start your car, it’s only moments...
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Chevrolet Colorado
The The 2012 Chevrolet Colorado is the perfect size pickup for running errands on the weekend and doing light duty chores around the yard. For those who don’t need a full size pickup, the Colorado offers almost everything a full...
How Long Does a Throttle Control Cable Last?
As As you drive through the streets and encounter different speed limits, you rely on the accelerator to speed up when needed. This is done through the use of the throttle control cable, which is also called the accelerator cable....