Q: High idle in the morning and after sitting for 5+ hours

asked by on October 06, 2016

When I start my truck in the morning, normal warm temperatures, the RPMs shoot up to 2500 and drops down to 1500-1800 and just fluctuates for about 10 seconds. Then the truck shakes a bit.

I went to a dealership that diagnosed no issues. No lights on or anything. They basically said they found large amount of carbon build up in the throttle body (which at 45k, I'm not sure if that's accurate). So they cleaned the throttle body and fuel system. Also they performed idle relearn and fuel composition relearn.

I've had my truck back about a week and it started fluctuating again. It was good for about a week.

So I'm skeptical to take it to another Chevy dealer or shop cause this shop couldn't find the issue. They just did something they thought would fix the issue.

Please help as I don't have much cash and I've wasted $200 on that useless trip to the dealership already.

Thanks!

My car has 45000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Engine idle speed is high Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote

Hi, thanks for writing in. I’d like to start by saying, you haven’t wasted your money. Even if your issue hasn’t been repaired, they did some quality maintenance that will help your truck last many more miles. I understand your frustration with this though. You went there for an issue that wasn’t taken car of.

I want to offer you another perspective about this. This may be a change to what you are used to with your truck, but the reality is it really isn’t a problem that does anything but create a higher idle than you are used to. I am certain something has changed, but determining what small change has occurred in a complicated system will most often take a lot of time to figure out. More time equals more money. More money for an issue that doesn’t seem to create a problem. So you need to decide, is it worth the money to figure out why this change has occurred?

As a technician, with my own car, I can tell when something has changed, but often it is too early to determine exactly what it was. I will often wait until the symptom becomes pronounced enough to easily figure out. I have that issue with my front end at this moment. It began to wonder slightly more on the highway. But chasing the problem now will likely lead to an inconclusive diagnosis. I will wait a bit longer until the play becomes more pronounced and I will know for sure. I would suggest that this method may be the most cost effective and least frustrating path. The alternative is hoping you have found a technician that has experienced your issue and has successfully found the source. Otherwise, you are likely to have the same experience.

If I were tasked to work on your car regardless, I would first smoke machine your motor looking for cold vacuum leaks while I had a scanner connected and monitoring all scan data. Even so, this may or may not reveal the source of the change.

If you would like a technician from YourMechanic take a crack at this, I recommend the following inspection: Engine idle speed is high inspection

Be sure to send the technician a note explaining this is a start up only condition.

Good luck!

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Won't start

A number of faults can occur when an engine overheats. If the engine was overheated severely, it is possible that the engine has internal damage and has seized. Also, engine electronics are very sensitive to heat and liquids. If coolant...

Coolant leaking quickly

A common problem with your truck is that the water pump will leak. It is possible that there may be another reason your truck is leaking as well. Perhaps a coolant hose, or your radiator has sprung a leak. I...

Car idles rough, extremely weak and stalls when put into gear

Hello. This can be caused by a number of things. I usually start by scanning the computer for codes. This will let me know if the computer is seeing any issues. If there are no codes then I take a...

Engine is overheating and heater does not work

As you may know, the heater not working in some cases may be related to the overheating problem you are also having. This may be due to a faulty heater blower motor or potentially a bad heater core. As you...

Kia Cerato 2011 jerks when accerating

Your car's engine intake system has something called a mass air flow sensor that monitors air intake as it is mixed with fuel prior to being injected into the motor. When this fails, this can cause an imbalanced air/fuel load...

AWD light stays on and I just had all 4 tires changed by a mechanic.

Hi there. The AWD light is coming on for the sensors on the wheels are picking up different tire rotational speeds. If you are putting on used tires and not new tires, then you will need to check the tire...

What is the name of the hose that is on the top of the fuel filter that it's connected to?

The inline fuel filter has 3 lines all combined in the area. The supply hose is connected to the fuel filter. The return hose is connected to the top of the fuel tank. The vapor return hose is connected to...

8000 first oil change

If your manual says to change the oil at 8000 miles then this is the official manufacturer recommendation. You have the choice to change the oil and filter sooner, but you will still need to monitor the oil level every...

Squeaking noise coming from under the hood upon cold start.

Hey there, thanks for writing in. The noise can be the serpentine belt tensioner not putting enough tension on the belt. In this case, you would most likely need to replace the tensioner along with the belt to resolve this...

Related articles

The Best Used Cars to Buy If You're a General Contractor
If If you're a general contractor, you probably aren’t in the market for a used car. More likely, you’re looking for a pickup truck, because you need to haul equipment and supplies to various job sites. Most contractors will likely...
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2011 Lincoln Town Car
2011 2011 marked the final year for Lincoln’s aging Town Car. It offered an immense amount of space in the front and the rear, as well as the iconic style for which the line was known. Key Features Perhaps...
2012 Toyota Prius vs. 2012 Chevrolet Volt: Which One Should I Buy?
While these two vehicles are both certainly cost-effective to drive, they can be difficult to compare due to the Prius’ entry in the mid-size category and the Volt living squarely in the compact car category. Both of these vehicles are...