Q: Had harmonic balancer replaced twice in 3 months, one week after fixing it the 2nd time the engine threw a rod

asked by on May 01, 2017

My harmonic balancer fell off, had it fixed, 3 months later it fell off again. Had it towed to the a shop to have it fixed again and a week after getting the car back it started making a terrible clicking clanking noise, had 2 different mechanics come check it out and they both agree the engine is garbage, they think it threw a rod. We never had any issues with the engine or noise prior, only after having the second mechanic "fix" it . Could the engine have died from the mechanic not fixing it properly or breaking something while replacing the harmonic balancer?

My car has 204000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

The only way to determine what is broken, and who is potentially responsible or at fault, is to physically examine the engine. Speculation in the absence of a physical, on site examination is not going to help you. If you are asking generally, "can a mechanic cause damage to my car?" of course the answer is emphatically yes and that is why you should be exceptionally careful in who you deal with and ALWAYS ask tons of questions in order to gauge "who" you are dealing with. An easy decision rule, covering ALL aspects of life, is don’t deal with anybody who doesn’t love to answer YOUR questions, in this case about your car, that you spent your hard earned money on.


With regard to the harmonic balancer, when the FIRST replacement was performed, that should have concluded it. That is, the first repair should have been lasting. As far as why the first repair failed, again hard to say without what we call a forensic exam, but a possibility is the pulley bolt may have been either under tightened or over tightened. Either mistake can cause the balancer to come off. If there is internal engine damage, the engine can be repaired or replaced. Either is no big deal and if you desire to consider your options, and costs, please simply contact YourMechanic and a certified mechanic will be dispatched to diagnose what you have and set out for you repair strategies. If you have further questions or concerns, do not hesitate to re-contact YourMechanic as we are always here to help you.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Check Engine codes. Need warranty for mechanic service work, any examples to ask for?

Hello there, thank you for asking about your 2001 Saab 9-3. These codes can come up if the engine needs a tune up, if it has bad coils, or even if you have dirty fuel injectors. Due to the age...

Leaking coolant

A cooling system pressure test should be performed to show the actual area of the issue. The water pump gasket, thermostat housing gasket, coolant hoses, radiator, heater hoses, or even the greater core could be the cause of the leak....

Air conditioning clutch is not engaging unless I bypass the relay.

It does sound like an issue with the pressure switch. When the switch fails, the compressor will not come on. Bypassing it turns on the compressor, which changes the pressure and allows the system to work. I would also check...

Changing the camshaft position sensor

You do not need to do anything special when replacing camshaft sensor. If you want a mechanic like one from YourMechanic to come and replace the cam sensor for you. You will need to clear the codes for the computer...

VSA coming on repeatedlyfor several times then off for several weeks then coming on again.

Hello, thank you for writing in. The VSA warning light relates to the vehicle stability control system. It functions with the ABS system to keep the vehicle on the road in difficult driving conditions. There are multiple sensors and systems...

How do you cancel cruise control?

Cruise control is definitely convenient, but it’s not something that can be used all the time. You’ll definitely need to cancel it at some point – generally at the first sign of brake lights ahead of you on the road....

How do I adjust the steering wheel of a 2012 Honda CR-V?

Adjusting the steering wheel is an important thing to do. Having the steering wheel adjusted to the optimal position for you will increase your ability to drive safely, and also increase your comfort. It’s very easy to adjust the steering...

How do I clean and maintain the seat belts?

Seat belts are pretty important to safety – they’re the most critical safety feature on your entire car. However, in order to work properly, they need to be cleaned and well maintained. Dirt and debris in the belt webbing can...

Jeep shut off while driving.

This may be a sign of a faulty ignition coil. Ignition coils are coated with a varnish-like insulation that becomes brittle over time after being stretched then contracted repeatedly The insulation develops small fractures that open when heated and close...

Related articles

The 5 Safest Used Cars You Can Buy For Under $20,000
The Subaru Legacy, Honda Accord, Ford Fusion, Chevy Volt, and the Volvo XC60 are five of the overall safest used cars you can buy for under $20,000.
How Much Does Physical Damage Affect the Value of a Used Car?
So, So, you've found the perfect used car. The color is right, it has navigation and even a sunroof! As you walk around it in awe, daydreaming about taking it down the highway with your favorite song playing, you see...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You Have Kids
Once Once you have kids, the kind of car you have becomes very important. Suddenly, the amount of space, entertainment features, reliability, safety, and easy to clean interior become the top priorities. Here’s a list of vehicles meant to satisfy...