Q: Bad shifter cable. 2002 Lexus ES300

asked by on August 31, 2016

My car has been in a Geico "preferred" shop due to accident (whole left side of car) for 16 days (they had to redo everything at least once). Prior to accident, no known problems. After the accident, car would not start on 3 occasions, each time only in heavy rainfall, but jumper cables did the trick & still driveable. Advised it was likely exposed wires from mirror that was ripped off getting wet (electrical). Literally the day I'm supposed to pick it up, suddenly it won't start, diagnosed "shifter cable is bad, car doesn't think it's in park", won't be covered, is going to cost me $1200! Again, NO known issues prior to this, very coincidental that it "broke" under their care. Am disputing with Geico, they say wear and tear, but from what I've read, it would have specific symptoms leading up to if that's the case. Car has started up even after diagnosis. need help if this is 100% wear and tear, or could have been damaged in the shop. It seems way too sudden and coincidence

My car has 129000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Hi there. When it comes to a vehicle getting in an accident and having issues with other components, this is a common problem that cannot be avoided at times. When the vehicle was looked at and quoted, the problem was not present and the insurance company is not in the business to fix all the problems that your car has - just the damage they seem to think was caused by the accident alone. The shifter cable is over 14 years old and may have been damaged by the accident, but it would be hard to prove unless something was bent or had physical damage to prove it. If you are skeptical about the diagnosis, you may want to have another expert inspect the shifter cable in person for a second opinion.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

What does the Service Transmission message mean?
The Service Transmission message can appear on the driver information center (DIC). When the DIC displays this alert, then the transmission is not operating properly and should be serviced as soon as possible.
Door ajar light on and doors only manually lock
All of the lock functions and rear wiper functions are controlled by the Body ECU. If the ECU is failing this could be the source of the issues. In the front door and in the rear door, there are both...
Won't start - 1996 Nissan Pathfinder
Yes, a possibility is the timing belt (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/timing-belt-replacement) has failed. However, it is also possible (and greatly preferred) that the gear driving the distributor has sheared off. Your engine is "probably" in that class of engines known as "interference engines"...
how much for a crankshaft positioning sensor and also how much to have a mechanic put one in
Hi there: Before you have one of our mobile mechanics replace the crankshaft position sensor, you should have them complete a full check engine light inspection (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/check-engine-light-is-on-inspection) first. It's possible that the code being displayed on your code reader is...
My Windshield delay wipers. 2012 Ford Explorer
Hi - there are 2 possible sources to this wiper shutoff (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-windshield-wiper-module) problem: is the delay mechanism itself - which is electronic - at fault, or the wiper "position" mechanism - which mechanically senses when the wiper arm returns to...
Oil pressure fluctuating and clicking noise from engine.
Hi there. The noise seems to be a lifter tap. Either a lifter is stuck or there is no oil to the lifter causing the rocker arm to tap and creating the noise you are hearing. Try putting one quart...
07 murano will not change gears..at 60 mph 3500 rpms code P1778
Hi there. The P1778 OBD-II trouble code is Nissan specific and indicates a problem with the step motor inside the transmission. The problem will be either with the electrical harness or the motor itself and will provide difficulty shifting. You...

Related articles

How a Manual Transmission Works
A A manual transmission helps a vehicle achieve a desired speed through the use of gears, a clutch, and a shifter. It works like this: when the driver wants to shift gears, he or she pushes in the clutch pedal...
How to Buy a Lexus
When buying a Lexus, consider your budget and which model you want. You should also run a vehicle history report and take a test drive before buying.
How to Report a Bad Driver
Bad drivers cause car accidents by driving too fast, tailgating, or ignoring road rules. Report reckless drivers to the authorities when you see them.