Q: Replacing a Cat 1

asked by on February 17, 2017

So I got an estimate from a shop to replace the Cat 1 in my 07 Ford Expedition and he said it would be $1000. I called a muffler shop in town and they told me about $360 because they would weld it. I know nothing about any of it so I'm trying to find out why the huge price gap and which one is better? Is the welding option a safe and reliable one?

My car has 133000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

There are two catalytic converters on the Expedition, one for each "bank" of the engine. Converter 1, corresponding to Bank No. 1 of the engine (passenger side of vehicle) has quite a bit of pipe integral with the converter and so what the muffler shop is thinking of doing is cutting out just the converter from the existing network of pipe and welding a "universal" converter back in. The universal converters retail for around $100 (of course, the shop’s cost is lower), so they are charging you roughly $260 for labor. If there is NOTHING wrong with the existing pipe, this is an acceptable, lower cost strategy assuming that the welding is done properly, that is there are ZERO exhaust gas leaks at the welds. If you opt for this, be sure you ask shop staff to run the engine and look specifically and carefully at the welded joints to be SURE there are no exhaust leaks. If there are leaks, the job is useless. Welding is acceptable if done properly but not everybody can do it properly.


The $1,000 quote, which by the way seems a little too "rounded off" to be credible (exactly, $1,000? what a coincidence?) might be based on the installation of the integral converter and associated piping. If you look on the Internet at Walker Part No. 54801 you will see the entire right side (Bank 1) converter assembly as vended for your vehicle. As you can see it is roughly $330 at retail. If they are using the entire assembly (Part No. 54801) that would imply a labor charge of $670 which is economically irrational unless they intend to assign a mechanic to work on your car for an entire week to do this one job.


You have a third option. You can get a quote from YourMechanic and get the quote based on having the whole assembly replaced (the $330 part, Walker Part No. 54801) which is a good solution because the other pipes in the right hand side converter assembly (again, see image on Internet that I referred you to) are likely to be corroded. And, with the whole assembly replaced, you do not have to worry about leaks from in-field welding. If you desire a quote, simply request converter replacement - bank 1. If you have further questions or concerns, do not hesitate to re-contact YourMechanic as we are always here to help you.

Was this answer helpful?
The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

Get a quote

What others are asking

Ran out of gas put gas in it but not getting to carburetor maybe it's the fuel filter

You should first try to replace the fuel filter and then with fuel line disconnected test to see if the fuel pump is pumping close to 5 psi of fuel pressure and is pumping fuel. When the vehicle ran out...

Why when I install a starter in truck it makes a lot of noise an then have to replace starter again the gears are grinded down

You may need to install a spacer to prevent the flywheel from touching the starter gear when the vehicle is running. This could be cause of both the noise and the worn down gears. If you need help with this...

Car won't start - replaced torque converter. 2005 Ford Expedition

Hi - if you are getting power to the starter solenoid - both the power cable from the battery, and the "start trigger" wire from the ignition switch, most likely the starter is no good - the solenoid at least....

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Ford F-250
When When it comes to large, heavy-duty pickup trucks, the 2012 Ford F-250 only has two competitors – the Chevrolet Silverado HD and the Dodge Ram 2500/3500. Though the F-250 doesn’t outperform the Ram in the towing department, it certainly...
How to Repair Scratches on a Car
Fixing car paint scratches can be easier than you might think. Inspect the scratch, clean your car, and use a touch-up kit to fix scratched car paint.
The Best Used Cars to Buy to Maximize Resale Value
A A car is not an investment. An investment, by definition, increases in value. A car is a necessary purchase, and it will never appreciate in value, with the possible exception of classics and antiques. So, as a used car...