Q: Replace run flat tires

asked by on July 28, 2016

I hit a pothole not to long ago and had to replace my tire. I have run flat tires with 40,000 miles on it. Do I have to replace all 4? I have run flat tires – tires resist the effects of deflation when punctured. What are your ideas? Thank you.

If you have run flat tires on your 2011 BMW 328 xDrive and that is your only restriction, then yes, you can only buy one tire and get away with it. If your vehicle is an all-wheel drive, you would need to replace all 4 tires. It is common for tires to be replaced at least in pairs, but if you don’t have to buy more than one tire most will not. The reason that all-wheel drive vehicles must replace all tires is that different tread depths all around the vehicle can have an affect on wheel speed, and therefore the computer can get very confused and possibly damage the transmission. Unless your vehicle is all-wheel drive, I would recommend just buying one tire with only 40K on all the other tires.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Engine lost power driving on the road
These issues could be caused by a number of problems. This could be anything from a mechanical issue (low oil pressure, intake air system leak, etc.) to an electrical problem (throttle position sensor, oxygen sensors, etc.). Since the Check Engine...
What does the front fog lamp light mean?
The front fog lamp light is located on your instrument panel. When the front fog lamps are turned on, the front fog lamp light will illuminate.
Multiple problems with my car.
I suggest you leave this extensive list of issues to a professional technician, such as the ones at YourMechanic for repair. These problems are likely unrelated and will require individual attention. The dash lights and horn are probably issues with...
toyota avensis transmission range sensor p0705 error registered when check engine
Hi there, thanks for writing in. The transmission range sensor error on your car is indicating a problem with the transmission range sensor circuit. Reduced fuel economy is a common symptom of this fault. This could be caused by a...
Car makes noise when taking off fast
You may need to have the engine mounts inspected to see if one is broken. This would be why you hear it in drive and not reverse; the engine may be moving and causing the noise. Have the noise checked...
Over heating and oil light comes on
This light will usually come on when one of two things are happening. Either the motor is in fact low on oil or the oil pressure sending unit (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/oil-pressure-sensor-replacement) is not working properly and may be producing a faulty reading....
Stalling, issues with the vapor canister and with adding fuel
Hello. The symptoms you describe can be caused by many things. If your vapor canister is having known issues then I would start there, as the vapor canister is tied into the vehicle's fuel system and can affect its performance....
When replacing rear brake pads on 2012 nissan rogue is it necessary to replace rotors at the same time?
Whenever brake pads are replaced the brake rotors must be resurfaced on a brake lathe or replaced outright. Putting new pads on a worn rotor is a guarantee that the new pads will wear irregularly, you will have vibration, and...
My car sounds like it want to cut off when I'm in Drive stopped at a light. 2004 Honda Accord
Hi there - first thing to do is check for problem codes, whether the Check Engine light is on or not. Most auto parts stores will do this for you for free on a "time-available" basis. There may be better...

Related articles

What Happens If I UnderInflate My Tires?
Your Your car’s tires have been specially matched to your vehicle. The size, type, and rating, as well as the optimum tire pressure are all factors in making sure your vehicle performs to its best ability. Changing your tire pressures...
How to Know What Tires to Buy
Your Your vehicle requires traction in order to accelerate, brake efficiently, and maintain control when you are steering. In order to do those things well, you need to own good tires on your vehicle. There are hundreds of different tire...
Understanding the BMW Condition Based Servicing and Service Indicator Lights
Car symbols, or dashboard lights, are a car service reminder. The BMW Condition Based Servicing system indicates when and what service your car needs.