Q: Motor mounts. Which mechanic is right?

asked by on October 25, 2016

I had all three of my motor mounts replaced 9 months ago with mechanic #1, and then my car began jerking when going into drive or reverse from park. The wheel vibrated at stops, and the car pulled during acceleration. Mechanic #2 said that all three were shot and the mechanic did not use a hydraulic mount like he should have.

I went back and told mechanic #1 and he said only the torque mount was bad, and replaced it for free with a different brand. The car still jerks when putting into gear though. Are the other two also bad? Or was mechanic #2 trying to sell me extra stuff?

My car has 119000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

If a motor mount diagnostic was performed and the mounts were confirmed to be faulty, the only safe repair strategy would have been to install dealer OEM motor mounts. If you use aftermarket parts in this application in essence you are using your time, money, and so forth to conduct an experiment with parts that, very often (not always, but VERY often) simply were not designed for your car. As a practical matter, the only way to determine if new motor mounts will resolve your issue is to install the mounts that were intended for your vehicle and those are the OEM dealer supplied mounts. If after installing the correct parts, you still have a vibration issue, at least at that point you can continue on with further diagnostics knowing that the mounts are NOT an issue. Motor mounts are not what they were years ago. Modern mounts have internal hydraulics and valving. There are many, many parts on a car which should not be repaired with aftermarket (or worse, rebuilt) parts if you desire to keep headaches to a minimum.

Was this answer helpful?
The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

Get a quote

What others are asking

When pressing gas pedal car starts to shake then stops when i let go

Hello, thank you for writing in. Due to the occurrence of your symptoms being related to the acceleration of the vehicle, it is likely that the vehicle is misfiring for one reason or another and causing an engine vibration. Misfires...

Why does my car shake at 60 mph

The tires, tie rods, and rack and pinion are the most common areas to look at for a vibration in the front end. The tires may be out of balance or have a stop leak inside one of them. The...

Car rattles and shakes when the foot is off the gas.

There could be an issue with one or both CV Shafts. The outer bearing assembly on the CV Shafts could be damaged or out of grease causing the joints to stick on deceleration making the vehicle shake and rattle. Jack...

Related articles

How to Get the Best Price on a Windshield Replacement
If If your windshield has a serious crack or is broken, you will need to have it replaced as soon as is possible. A seriously damaged or broken windshield can impair your visibility, and offers less protection in the event...
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Ball Joint (Front)
Common signs include clunking noises and excessive vibration from the front, and you may start steering to the right or left unintentionally.
How Long Does a Driveshaft Last?
When When it comes to important components in your vehicle, the driveshaft holds a lot of importance. This part is responsible for delivering the torque, or power, that is being made by your engine and sending it to the correct...