Q: Misfires with scoring on inside of cylinder 1

asked by on May 16, 2016

My first cylinder keeps eating sparking plugs and throwing misfire codes. I put a scope in there and found scoring on the cylinder walls. It looks like it might have had a leaking head gasket. It runs okay once the built up coolant burns up. Do you think I should put in a new head gasket, or get a re-manufactured engine? Any other advice?

Hello, I would not recommend that you replace only the head gasket, because of the scoring on the cylinder walls that will still remain. This could lead to a loss of compression over time and cause the engine to run poorly and lose power. For this reason, it would be best to replace the engine.

Your options when replacing an engine are getting one that is remanufactured or getting a used engine from a salvage company that is in good condition. Although a used engine will be less expensive, there is always a greater risk of having other issues or that the used engine will fail prematurely. A remanufactured engine is more expensive but is generally of better quality.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Need new shocks
Hi there. A common sign of a bad shock is fluid leaking from the shock itself. A leaking shock Will deem the shock in need of replacement. An alternative way to diagnose a shock is to go over speed bumps....
Window not closing
Hi there. A common cause of a window not going up is the window switch itself. Also a window that is off its track or a bad motor can cause this as well. A mechanic sent by YourMechanic can be...
Continuous clicking when pushing Start button
The problem is unlikely related to spark plugs or a capacitor. I would recommend having your battery tested, and replaced, if necessary. After your battery is replaced, your throttle should be relearned with a professional scan tool. There is also...
No air coming through any of the vents, defrost, etc.
It sounds like you may have got something stuck in the blower for the A/C. The blower may be blocked or may have burned up. Have the blower removed and tested and checked for a problem. You may have something...
I am installing a timing belt on a crate motor. The intake side camshaft tdc marks do not line up perfectly like the exhaust side
Hello. If there was not a timing belt on the engine already then you need to be careful about turning everything. As long as you are taking it easy and being vigilant of any binding you can turn each of...
After changing radiator and oil, car stalls when coming to stop. Is the motor damaged?
Hello. Stalling can be caused by many things. If the engine is no longer overheating, then it is unlikely that the stalling is directly related to the radiator repair. A few common causes for stalling when braking are a faulty...
The traction control light comes on until the ignition is switched off, then it is off for a short time, then on again.
As you may know, your car is equipped with wheel speed sensors (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/abs-speed-sensor-replacement) on each of the four wheels, which monitor wheel speed while relaying this information to the traction control module, which is controlled by the car's ECU. When...
Can I swap a 97 4.3 with a 94 4.3?
Hi there. You can change the engine block, but the cylinder heads will not match up. The cylinder heads for a 94 was made for an intake with a throttle body and injection in the throttle body where the 97...
Engine stops and jerks while driving
Hi There, Your car has a small purge valve called a purge solenoid (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/evaporation-vent-solenoid-replacement) in the Evaporative Emissions system that controls the venting of fumes from the fuel tank as these fumes build up inside, particularly when you are refueling...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Jeep Grand Cherokee
Though Though the Jeep Grand Cherokee is not a new model, it got a complete redesign in 2011, and the 2012 Jeep Grand Cherokee saw even more improvements. While other SUV manufacturers have sat on their laurels, Jeep has done...
How to Install a Camshaft
Over Over the years, engines (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-a-modern-engine-works) have evolved in so many ways. Most of the changes or improvements that have been done revolve around creating better performance and fuel economy, without making the engine larger. One of the biggest changes...
How to Troubleshoot a Car Exhaust or Engine Noise
Car exhaust systems and car engines make whirring, clicking, or sputtering noises if there's a faulty belt, alternator, water pump, or tension pulley.