Q: Misfires with scoring on inside of cylinder 1

asked by on May 16, 2016

My first cylinder keeps eating sparking plugs and throwing misfire codes. I put a scope in there and found scoring on the cylinder walls. It looks like it might have had a leaking head gasket. It runs okay once the built up coolant burns up. Do you think I should put in a new head gasket, or get a re-manufactured engine? Any other advice?

Hello, I would not recommend that you replace only the head gasket, because of the scoring on the cylinder walls that will still remain. This could lead to a loss of compression over time and cause the engine to run poorly and lose power. For this reason, it would be best to replace the engine.

Your options when replacing an engine are getting one that is remanufactured or getting a used engine from a salvage company that is in good condition. Although a used engine will be less expensive, there is always a greater risk of having other issues or that the used engine will fail prematurely. A remanufactured engine is more expensive but is generally of better quality.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Noise when i turn heater on for while to defrost or vents. 2003 Chevy Impala

Hi there, thanks for writing in about your 2003 Chevrolet Impala. The noise you may be hearing is the blend door actuator clicking until the door gets into the position it needs to be in. When these actuators go bad...

dashboard lights won't turn on

Hi there: This issue is typically caused by a blown fuse in the fuse box located on the driver side of the vehicle. It could also be due to a bad electrical relay that powers these lights. To know for...

P0016

Hi...Diagnostic Trouble Code P0016 has many causes other than a failed camshaft position sensor. Other possible causes for Code P0016(https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/p0016-obd-ii-trouble-code-camshaft-position-a-camshaft-position-correlation-bank-1-by-jay-safford) to set include: the camshaft timing is wrong because the timing chain jumped teeth; the camshaft phaser is out of...

Engine light came on after washing engine 2 days later then went off and oil lamp came on three times - driving - went off.

Well, you have a couple of questions here and not a lot to go on, so I'll address them as best I can. Your Check Engine light indicates that a trouble code from a sensor has been registered in the...

Leaking inside the car after the rain

A few things can cause water to leak into the car. The most common would be the windshield leaking through, bad door or window seals, an AC evaporator core leaking, or one of the body seams allowing water to pass...

My car isn't staying charged after a jump, it lasts about two minutes before the engine dies. I'm wondering if it's the alternator.

This may be related to a couple of different things. The fact that it must be jumped to get it started is usually a sign of a dead battery or an alternator that may not be working. In rare cases...

Humming sounds during driving over 30 mph

The inner and outer edges of the tire tread wall on the affected side where the noise is coming from needs to be inspected for a cupping or cupping wear pattern. These types of wear patterns can produce a noise...

I have a 2011 town n country. I was told by the service dept. that the left side cylinder head needed replacement which

As long as the cost of replacing the spark plugs on the right side is equal to half of the cost of doing it on the total engine I think it will be ok. Considering that the cylinder head is...

Misfire and P0420

Hello - the P0420 and the inconsistent waveform for the post-cat O2 sensor might be related to your failing intake manifold gasket issue. If tiny droplets of coolant are being sucked into the engine - one failure mode for this...

Related articles

How to Replace an Engine Mount
The engine mounts keep the motor in place. They need to be replaced if there is excessive vibration, impact noises under the hood, or engine movement.
How to Understand Compression and Power Systems in Small Engines
Being familiar with basic compression and power system functions of a four-stroke engine can help you diagnose and fix issues with your car.
What Do the Belts on the Front of an Engine Do?
Car serpentine belts power multiple parts like the power steering pump and air conditioning. A broken engine belt can cause damage to components.