Q: Loud knocking from motor that randomly started while driving down the road at 45 mph.

asked by on November 02, 2016

Oil was fine a week ago then when my car started knocking loudly I checked oil again. It was online but boarderline black. It's been changed, herd the oil pump enagged so I know it's not that. I'm afraid to drive it now.... because I have a feeling it's a rod knock which as I have been reading requires an R&R. Correct? Oh btw car knocks loud when at a stop but does idal at 700 rpm.

My car has 119000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Car is making a noise Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote

If the oil is not being consumed, it will turn black due to heat and carbon buildup. If the oil passages were dirty with carbon and other buildup, then the new oil acts as a detergent and will pick up the debris. Excess heat will also cause the color to turn. Different oil types will react differently to heat. Since the oil is not being depleted, your attention should be drawn to the excess heat.

The most likely cause for both the excess heat and the knock is bad spark. Issues with spark usually include a weak or mistimed signal. If the combustion happens at the wrong time, the result is the knocking you are hearing. You may notice the knock at idle due to the lack of other engine noises and a lower frequency of sounds to drown out the noise. Failure of the rod bearings on the crankshaft can also cause these sounds. It is more likely on an engine as old as yours. You are correct that an overhaul is likely required if this is the case, which is why you may want to see if the spark is causing your issue first. You can do this by checking your timing and spark plug condition.

Either way, I recommend having a certified mechanic, such as one from YourMechanic, come to your location to determine the source of the sound and see what repairs are necessary.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

What does the Engine Oil Low – Add Oil message mean?

The Engine Oil Low – Add Oil message will appear on your driver information center (DIC) when the oil level is too low in your engine. When more oil is added, this alert will no longer be displayed on the...

Brake, traction, and service lights on

Hello. If this occurred right after a brake line was fixed then there may be low brake fluid in the vehicle or there may be a pressure switch failure. I would double check the brake fluid just to see if...

1999 Toyota Celica, starts and "moves" fine (engages) but slow starting, like driving thru quicksand. No other problems but check

Hi There, Generally, the check engine light comes on when something fairly serious is going on with the vehicle. This can happen for many different reasons such as a faulty mass air flow sensor, a faulty O2 sensor, a bad...

Car hood won't open

Hello. Overtime hood springs will loose the ability to force the hood up when the hood latch is pulled. It's best to have an extra set of hands when trying to get it open so one may pull the hood latch...

driving and car cut off brakes lock and it want start even though it will turn over like it is going to start

The brakes need the engine to run to supply vacuum to the brake booster. This is why brakes are hard. The engine cut off can be from several reasons including a broken timing belt, bad fuel pump and loss of...

car overheating and heater blowing cold air plus hose to heater core not getting hot

If you replaced all those parts and it still is overheating then you have a radiator that is clogged and/or the fan is not working. You need to see if the upper and lower hose is hot when the vehicle...

Hard shifting, high revving

Hello. It is possible that the transmission is faulty and may need to be replaced for your 2007 Chevrolet Express 2500. It sounds like the transmission valve body is overheating and causing the shifting problem you are experiencing. The clutches...

My car is stuttering as I drive

If you are continuously filling up the oil, and see no signs of a leak, then the engine is consuming the oil. This can happen two ways. The oil can seep into the combustion chambers, or can be burned on...

Dash and headlights flash for about 1 minute after shut off

Hi there. It sounds like the lighting system has feedback through another circuit. This could be due to a short circuit, open circuit, missing/failed ground point, corroded ground point, corroded connector, loose connector, or relay block faults. With the age...

Related articles

How Does Oil Lubricate an Engine?
Oil is an essential fluid in your car engine. Motor oil lubricates engine parts and prevents car overheating. Changing oil helps extend engine life.
Is it Safe to Drive With a Faulty Knock Sensor?
Symptoms of a bad or failing engine knock sensor include slow acceleration, reduced fuel economy, and the Check Engine Light turning on.
How to Properly Store Motor Oil
Some drivers like to store oil for future oil changing needs. Keep the container sealed and in a cool, dark place to make your oil last longer.