Q: When driving over puddle, water intrusion caused car to shut off

asked by on July 08, 2016

My car has 107,000 miles. While it was raining during a storm, I drove over a puddle at about 25 mph and my car shut off. I had to have it towed to the dealership and they reported to me that it was water intrusion that had caused the car to quit. They also said that the rod had failed and had gone through the aluminum motor both times. The air breather that is positioned under the motor is what caused the water intrusion. They didn’t know about the powertrain. Should I insist that they check the powertrain?

Transmission Fluid Service $140.08 - $502.73 Get a Quote
Car is stalling Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

Hi there. If the engine sucked enough water into it to cause a rod to fail and go through the block then the engine will need to be replaced. As for he rest of the power train it will be hard to determine if there are any other issues until the engine is replaced since it cannot be driven.

Most of the time, the transmission will be fine after going through a large amount of water as long as the fluid is maintained.

If you’d like a second opinion on this, feel free to contact a certified mechanic who can diagnose the cause of the stall to confirm my suspicions. Good luck.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Fixing the oil leak on the nuts holding the valve cover
No, I work on that all the time. It's a very easy job. What you'd want to buy is a valve cover gasket kit that includes rummets for the spark plugs and rounded bolts. Even if you are not a...
How do you know if its really a timing chain gasket? And how long does it take to repair?
It is more likely that the water pump is leaking from its front seal. The leak will show up from the center of the motor area and will drip off the bottom of the timing cover. The timing cover on...
My motor sounds like it is forced.
Hello. It sounds like you have a transmission that is slipping (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/is-it-safe-to-drive-with-a-slipping-transmission) from the description you are giving. Some things that should be checked when experiencing slipping symptoms are the low or dirty transmission fluid (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/transmission-fluid-service), clutch problems, failing shift...
The truck is from Georgia which doesn't have smog control. In California it won't pass smog. It has a new motor and transmission.
Hi, the blue-grey smoke you mention is your engine burning oil, probably due to worn piston rings or valve guides and seals. This is expected from an engine with 300K miles on it. Unfortunately for you, California has pretty stringent...
My transit van's powertrain light is coming on. Is it easy to fix, how long will it take, and is it costly?
Hi there. It would be really hard to say what it will cost to fix and how long it will take without knowing first what is going on. This light can come on for a number of reasons, some of...
On a 2008 enclave there is a p0018 code. How do you know if it's a failed sensor or timing chain?
Hi there. Locate the crankshaft position sensor and check for power to it with the key on. If there is power, then with using a paper clip to back probe the wiring with the plug installed on the sensor, check...
How do you remove the alternator I have a 2010 toyota venza v6
On a vehicle that has a transverse mounted engine, you may need to start by removing the passenger front wheel and splash guard. This is not always necessary but will help to access the tensioner and serpentine belt. Once the...
My 2014 dodge journey has tried to overheat 2 times in 6 weeks. Both times tge coolant level was low.
Hello there. If the dealership has indicated that you have coolant inside of a cylinder, then it is quite likely that the head gasket failed, causing coolant to seep into the oil galleys and into the combustion chamber. However, a...
oil change
It sounds like the facility that performed your oil change may have forgotten to refill the motor with oil after draining the old oil. If there were no signs of visible smoke, smells or oil leaking anywhere, it is quite...

Related articles

6 Essential Things to Know About Horsepower
Horsepower Horsepower is one of those terms that everyone recognizes, but just try asking someone what it means. You’ll more than likely receive a blank stare or a quickly mumbled response that doesn’t really help. The following are six things...
How to Remove Cylinder Head Bolts
Removing Removing the head is a major step in removing the cylinder head (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-to-buy-a-good-quality-cylinder-head). These head bolts hold the cylinder head to the engine block. The head bolts are long bolts that go through the cylinder head and head gasket...
5 Cases Where You Should Call a Tow Truck
In situations where a mechanic cannot get to you, or cannot drive your car to a shop, calling a tow truck is the best option.