Q: Transmission intermittently won't shift to next gear

asked by on July 26, 2016

My car has a SMG transmission. The problem began around 1 month ago and it is intermittent. Sometimes the transmission won’t shift at all, no matter which gear the car is in. Sometimes the gear that it is in won’t change. I have to take my foot off the gas pedal so that it will shift. When on the highway, if I go from first-second-third- then it won’t shift into fourth and I have to take my foot off the gas to get it to shift into fifth. One time, while changing gear with the paddle shift, it stopped at 2nd and a SMG light came on telling me to check the dealership. So I took the car to the BMW dealer and they ran a diagnostic on the transmission. They said that the transmission stopped at third gear and it didn’t shift any more. Then, they told me that I needed a new transmission. That doesn’t make sense to me since I can still shift the gear. The SMG doesn’t shift some times, even when on 5th and driving on the highway, it won’t shift into 6th until I take my foot off the gas. I’ve heard different analysis of the problem - computer - reset battery, etc. Do you think my car needs a new SMG transmission, and if not, what do you suggest?

It is very possible that the transmission may require a full rebuild or a replacement in order for it to perform properly. Although you are able to shift into other gears, if certain gears are not working correctly, transmission damage may be the cause.

If the transmission has already been diagnosed by the dealer that it needs replacement and the transmission is still not shifting properly, it is unlikely that the transmission will get any better without replacement.

It does not hurt to attempt any reset procedure that may be available, but it is also unlikely that a reset of any kind will resolve transmission issues. Small things to check before replacing the transmission if possible would be the fluid level and any trouble codes that may have been stored due to the issue your transmission is causing.

If any codes exist, this may lead you to other possible parts inside the transmission that may be able to be replaced and have your transmission working again as it should. You can get a second opinion from an local expert, such as one from YourMechanic, in order to diagnose your shifting problem and advise you on the next steps.

Was this answer helpful?
The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

Get a quote

What others are asking

Is getting a 2010 BMW M3 with 70,000 miles used as a daily driver expensive annually?

Hello. Though this vehicle will be fun to drive, it will be much more expensive to maintain then the Infiniti is. The cost for every service is more expensive, and normal wear parts like brakes and tires will typically cost...

Jerking while shifting from second gear into third gear

This issue could be something as simple as a reprogramming of the transmission computer, to a broken motor mount (although the jerking would probably be felt in all gear ranges), to possibly a transmission malfunction. Unfortunately, the transmission module reprogramming...

Sunroof not working.

If the clutch pedal goes down without engaging the clutch. The fluid level needs to be checked in the clutch reservoir. If the level is good then there is a bad seal on either the master or slave cylinder. If...

Related articles

The Best Used Cars to Buy If You’re Shorter Than Average
Vertically Vertically challenged? Hate getting behind the wheel and having to crane your neck to see? There’s nothing wrong with you, but there is something wrong with your car. It might be time to trade it in and take advantage...
How to Use a BMW With Comfort Access Technology
The The BMW comfort access technology was introduced in 2002 as a keyless remote system that uses sensors to detect where the owner is in proximity to the vehicle within 1.5 meters (about 5 feet), allowing him or her to...
5 Signs Your Car Isn't Shifting Correctly
Improper shifting is a sign of car transmission problems. The solution might be simple or complex, but get it inspected to avoid expensive repairs.