Q: Should I sell my car or pay for the repairs?

asked by on September 20, 2016

I just got this car in June. My dad bought it from a family friend he didn't look for a car fax on it or asked about the major issues. So he just went by what they said. A month into it, the car started jumping when switching to different rpm's my mechanic said it was fine it just might need to be replaced. I got new tires and an oil change. After a few weeks I took it back to the mechanic to get a tire alignment and he told me that before I could consider a tire alignment I needed to replace my rack and pinion and replace my brake line which he told me that if I got it replaced that it would make it safe to drive but won't last much longer. My transmission is getting worse everytime I drive it. It has trouble starting when it's below half a tank. Should I spend the money on the replacement or should I just invest in a newer car?

My car has 248653 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

I would first get a quote for all the repairs needed after a thorough complete inspection of all major systems. Get quotes on all the problems including replacing the transmission and rack and pinion. Once you have a price for all the repairs then get a trade in value at a local car dealer that has newer vehicles that you like. Once you have the cost of repairs and the value of the car as a trade in you can then make a decision on completing the repairs or replacing the vehicle as is.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Sliding door not closing.
The door is on a track and on rollers in that track. If the track is blocked or the rollers are broke could bind the door. The door has several safety items that cannot tell the difference between someone in...
Four-wheel-drive won't go into gear
Hello, there seems to be two common reasons behind why your Dodge Dakota will not engage its’ four wheel drive. The first reason is due to the wiring harness for the four wheel drive selector switch. Over time rubbing on...
Hear clicking sound when air conditioner is on
The clicking noise is most likely being emitted by one of the actuators that control the ducts in your air conditioning system. When they go bad they often make the clicking noise you are referring to. Depending on where the...
2.5L 2.7L L LS 5 SPEED AIR INTAKE KIT + FILTER
Yes. This will replace your existing filter and housing. If you need help with this, a professional from YourMechanic can come to you to replace or install the air intake (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/cold-air-intake-replacement) for you.
What may cause my transmission to jerk?
These types of rough running issues are very hard to diagnose without taking a look at the vehicle and doing some diagnostic testing. This could be caused by the vehicle needing a tune up (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/tune-up), a fuel pressure problem, a...
Do you reccomend replacing the rear self leveling air shocks with just standard gas shocks, or stick with the self leveling?
The rear coil springs that were installed on the vehicle in the load leveling versus non load leveling models are different (I checked the GM parts catalog to confirm). Inasmuch as the spring and the shock were matched for handling...
For some reason one of my headlights looks dirtier than the other. I've tried just about everything to get it to look new again an
Hi there. Over time, many different items can cause headlights to fade. In most cases, it's a caused by debris that naturally builds up on the lens that causes it to become cloudy. In other cases, the inner seal that...
Car rattling noise upon acceleration
Hello, thank you for writing in. The clanking noise is likely associated with the brake system or the CV joints. You will want these inspected first before looking to anything else. CV joints wear down and fall out of alignment....
Can i put a 3.5 v6 Nissan Altima sedan engine & transmission in a 2.5s nissan altima sedan
Hi there. This can be done but the cost of it would be ridiculous.You would need all of the computer and the wiring harness from the donor vehicle to make it work in your vehicle. It wouldn't be cost effective....

Related articles

A Buyer's Guide to the 2012 Honda Crosstour
There There could be a number of reasons an SUV isn’t right for you: the price, the size, their mpg, etc. However, there could also be a number of reasons you’d really like to have some extra space. If that’s...
How to Replace a Lost or Stolen Car Title in Wyoming
Are Are you familiar with what a car title is? It is the proof that you are the owner of your vehicle. So why is this so important? Well if you have any plans of selling your car in the...
How to Replace a Lost or Stolen Car Title in Maine
Your Your car title is what proves you are the legal owner of your vehicle. If you own your vehicle, it is essential you also have the car title. With that said things can happen and your title may become...