Q: Should I replace both front struts at the same time?

asked by on November 05, 2016

Hi, I have a S-trim AWD Chrysler 200 and I think I bent (or "popped") the front left strut going over a dip (or dips) too fast. Generally, I can't tell a difference in the handling; the coil seems totally fine but if I'm going over a particularly bumpy road at a relatively low speed I'll hear a sharp knocking or rattling sound. If I'm at a total stop and I turn the wheel all the way to the left SOMETIMES I will hear a pop or single knock. It looks like there's some sort of grease buildup in the sleeve of the strut. Can provide pictures if needed. Now, it's been several months (probably almost a year) since I first noticed symptoms, and I have a replacement strut, but if I'm changing one side should I also go ahead and change the OTHER side at the same time? Thank You.

My car has 17000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Strut Assembly Replacement $292.45 - $2376.59 Get a Quote

Hi there. I recommend replacing both struts for the front at the same time, as they have springs that control the ride height and also have shocks that control the tire-to-road contact. Plus, you will not have to worry about the other strut failing any time soon.

If you need further assistance with your vehicle, then seek out a professional, such as one from YourMechanic, who can come to your location to replace the struts.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I use the low traction mode?
Your vehicle may be equipped with an Allison Transmission or a Hydra-Matic 6-Speed Automatic Transition. If so, you will have a Low Traction Mode that can make it much easier to drive your car in inclement weather or slippery conditions...
The car cannot start, there is no cranking
It is very possible that the Drive Authorization System is preventing the vehicle from starting. The system needs about 12.6v to operate properly, so battery voltage needs to be checked with the key. If battery voltage is good, then there...
Won't start right away. Chugs while excellerating .
Your 1995 Buick LeSabre has two different problems: The hard start problem is the fuel pressure not being maintained after shut down. This can be caused by the fuel pump (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/fuel-pump-replacement) in the tank or the pressure regulator (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/fuel-pressure-regulator-replacement) on...
High idling
This may be a sign of a failing idle air control valve. The idle air control valve is located on or near your intake manifold and monitors the air intake as it is mixed with fuel prior to being injected...
Car shakes when I apply brakes doing 45mph or more and even when I don't apply brakes around 60 mph 2005 Chevy Equinox
Hello - you likely have multiple problems here: one of which exaggerates the others. Given your mileage, your front struts are likely worn (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-strut-assembly). This is important because the tire imbalance you feel at 60 mph (without braking), and the...
Will bad engine coils cause the car to not want to accelerate?
Faulty ignition coils can certainly reduce engine power. Ignition coils provide electricity (anywhere from 25 to 50,000 volts) to the spark plugs. That spark ignites the fuel mixture, which forces the pistons down and creating horsepower. With two faulty coils,...
HELLO . WELL I TOOK MY CAR TO AUTOZONE TO GET IT PLUGGED INTO THE SYSTEM TO SEE WHAT WAS WRONG WITH IT. A CODE ASDVISED THAT I NE
It sounds like you may have a vacuum leak of some kind resulting in the code you have indicated. Although there are several codes that may cause this, in general they will usually refer back to an air or vacuum...
2005 Cadillac CTS 3.6L V6 having transmission issues
The code P0430 is for the catalytic convertor or the sensors for the catalyst is having a problem. This may be from a bad catalyst or a defective sensor. Most likely this code was already there and the last owner...
Engine still rocks back and forth. What can it be?
If you are using aftermarket mounts, that introduces a bit of a complexity in diagnosing a problem such as this as aftermarket parts can always be a potential cause of fit and function problems after installation. The only way to...

Related articles

How Often Does the Suspension System Require Routine Maintenance?
Keeping Keeping a car, truck, or other vehicle running safely and efficiently requires a certain amount of routine maintenance. Most owners know that they’re supposed to get their oil changed periodically, but what about the suspension — what routine maintenance...
What Are Leaf Springs?
A A leaf spring is a component of some vehicles’ suspension systems. Specifically, a leaf spring is composed of several (or occasionally just one) thin strips of metal, called leaves, arranged on top of each other to form a single...
How to Install Aftermarket Springs
Switching Switching out your stock springs (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-long-do-suspension-springs-last) for aftermarket springs can have a huge impact on your car. Whether you’re going for a sporty feeling, or even just a different look by lowering the car, new springs can make your...