Q: Scraping noise shifting gears

asked by on September 08, 2016

I started having transmission problems when shifting from 1st to 2nd gear or from 3rd down to 2nd gear. 2nd would make a scraping noise. It usually happened at higher rpms above 4500 to 5000. I wasn’t aggressively shifting either. Then I did a test drive with the dealership and they replaced the transmission. It helped but the problem started right back up again. I have had experience driving manual transmissions, too. Do you have any ideas or suggestions on this?

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I reactivate the auto-up and auto-down features?
The auto-up and auto-down features allow you to entirely roll up or down a power window with one press of a button. Sometimes the auto-up and auto-down functions stop working, and need to be reactivated. To do this, pull the...
How do I use the temperature control?
The temperature control knob is located in the climate control cluster, on the center console. The knob controls how hot or cold the air coming out of your vents is. If you turn the knob counter-clockwise, the air will get...
Wheel and ignition locked up
If you own a spare key, try turning the key in the ignition to see if this will work. If it does not turn the ignition, then look at your key and see if it is worn out. A worn...
I got rust in my engine is there a way to get rid of it in truck?
The rear ABS sensor is mounted in the top of the rear differential. I am not sure if your question is about rust in your engine? Can you clarify the question? You also mention a problem about the engine dying...
After alternator is replaced, battery light still comes on
Hello. It is possible that the problems that you have been experiencing with the bad alternators (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/alternator-replacement) have damaged the battery (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/battery-replacement) causing it to be weak. This would make the Battery Light (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/battery-light-is-on-inspection) come on. It is also possible...
Loss of power
Hi there, thanks for writing in. Most of the time this is caused by a fuel system issue. I typically check the fuel pressure first. If the pressure is low, then the pump is bad (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-fuel-pump). If the pump is...
Heavy white smoke from exhaust(2001 Nissan Frontier supercharged)will not start after.
Hi there: Usually heavy white smoke is a sign of serious internal engine damage such as worn out piston rings or worn cylinder head valve guides. It could also be an oil control valve that is damaged. Regardless, the white...
My car is taking off in second gear
Is the Check Engine Light on or could a fault code be stored in the computer? To see if there is a fault code stored in the computer without the presence of an illuminated Check Engine Light, the car will...
oil leak: 2008 passat 2.0t driver side near battery down below, leaks oil onto a hose.
Hello, thank you for writing in. The lack of oil in your car until you get this fixed should be a concern. Make sure you are keeping an eye on the oil level and adding some when needed. The oil...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 BMW X5 xDrive35d
The The 2012 BMW X5 xDrive35d offer contour seats and smooth acceleration. The suspension offers a smooth ride to the driver and passengers in the vehicle, even for long road trips. It can handle tight curves without any problem while...
Top Automotive News & Stories: July 27-August 3
Each week we compile the best announcements and developments from the world of cars. Here are the topics you can’t miss from July 27 to August 3. Most Stolen Cars List Released most stolen cars...
How to Shift From First to Second Gear in a Manual Transmission Car
Shifting from first to second gear in a manual transmission requires accuracy and practice, as well as a feel for the car.