Q: Problems after thermostat, digital cluster & cooling pump replacements

asked by on July 25, 2016

My car had the thermostat, cooling pump, and digital cluster replaced. The dealership told me, on that same day, that the new cluster was defective due to the fuel gauge wouldn’t function properly. They replaced it a few days later. Then the cluster was replaced ‘again’ when the speedometer needle was stuck and stayed below the zero mark. After picking up my car I had driven less than a mile and the digital cluster faded to a blank screen. Immediately I went back to the shop and was told they would have to order another cluster and would call me, which they did a few days later. Now… the digital cluster won't make any warning sounds. When manually pressing on the button to test it, it shows a service visit was coming up and had the symbol to check the oil level and water pump. I was told by the tech that this is normal thing to see. That statement contradicts the car manual. I read where an authorized dealer in another state replaced the thermostat and cooling pump for a problem like this. I went back to the dealer explaining the no-alarm failure in the cluster and… Now the car has a slight jerk forward when I press the brake pedal. Strangely, the report reads: “ car ran rough, the panel lights were flashing and the car sat for a long period of time.” It also said that the transmission needed replacement and the cluster was fine. The tech told me that the car was in good shape, no alarm except for the transmission and it wasn't bad. But after getting home, the paperwork/inspection report showed that every component needed further attention. I phoned and the service advisor agreed that the technician must have made a mistake. What is your advice to get my car working properly?

Spark Plugs Replacement $98.11 - $669.97 Get a Quote
Battery Replacement $232.05 - $347.15 Get a Quote
Alternator Replacement $151.62 - $1237.14 Get a Quote
Fuel Pump Replacement $129.49 - $1234.40 Get a Quote
Car idle is rough Inspection $79.99 - $99.99 Get a Quote

It appears you may have a few different issues going on. It seems unlikely that more than one cluster would fail. The most likely cause is a shorted wiring or open circuit causing the clusters to fail. If the car is running roughly, there are a few potential causes, such as the spark plugs, battery, alternator, vacuum leak, or fuel pump. You may want to take this back in to have it looked at by the dealer. If you would like an independent mechanic to give this look, a certified professional from YourMechanic can come to your home or office to diagnose why your vehicle is running rough.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Hello! I drive a 2017 chevy malibu. I got into a small wreck and hit a ditch and when I got pulled out, my car was driving fine for about 25-30 miles than it started overheating and when I got out, I saw that my [radiator](/topics-radiator-chevy/) fluid was pouring out. Now I cant keep any fluid in the radiator, even without driving it. The radiator is on the right side when looking under the hood and the leak is coming from the left sign.

Battery died brakes locked up

This vehicle is equipped with vacuum assisted power brakes. When the engine is off, government regulations state that there must be enough vacuum in reserve to enable the brake pedal to be pushed down at least two to three more...

Car shuts of only in drive, at a red light.

This may be a sign of a faulty MAP sensor as the vehicle responds adversely to a load put on the motor (i.e. putting it in gear, making turns (which makes use of the power steering pressure switch) turning on...

Hard shutter or vibrate at turning low speeds

Hello, thank you for writing in. If the issues started after the work that was most recently done, you want to verify that those repairs were done right and are holding. If the vibration and shaking were present before hand,...

How do you remove the master cylinder sensor or plug

The plug in the master cylinder reservoir can be removed by just grabbing the tip with a pliers and twist to brake the seal and remove the plug. The sensor can be removed by using a small screwdriver and releasing...

My car trembles or idles hard when I'm at a temporary stop. It feels like the car wants to move before I'm ready.

This problem may be related to a dirty or faulty idle air control valve. This valve is a unit that reads the air intake as it is mixed with fuel, prior to being injected into the motor. The computer then...

Wheel hop/ wobble

Hello. There are several components that may be causing these symptoms. The easiest to check is the condition of the tires. If they are cracked, warped, low, misaligned then you will possibly have these symptoms. More likely it is related...

vanos solenoid bmw

The nature of the repair will have to do with the faults stored in the DME (engine computer). Spark plugs, though rated at 100K miles, have a service life of about 60K miles and should be replaced at tht mileage....

Seat belt sensors malfunction when car sits in heat

Hello. This is caused by the female part of the seat belt failing. The sensor in the receiver fails internally and will usually be susceptible to changes in temperature when it fails. It will need to be tested and replaced...

Related articles

How to Diagnose a Stalling Car
It’s It’s incredibly frustrating to have a car that stalls and it always seems to happen at the worst possible time – like when you’re in middle of a busy intersection with fifty enraged drivers behind you. There are a...
4 Essential Things to Know About Running Out of Gas
While it would be nice if it wasn’t so, every vehicle can run out of gas. The good thing, however, is...
What Does the Jack Mode Warning Light Mean?
The jack mode warning light lets you know when your car is suspended at a certain height, which may make it easier to perform service or repair on it.