Q: Problems after thermostat, digital cluster & cooling pump replacements

asked by on July 25, 2016

My car had the thermostat, cooling pump, and digital cluster replaced. The dealership told me, on that same day, that the new cluster was defective due to the fuel gauge wouldn’t function properly. They replaced it a few days later. Then the cluster was replaced ‘again’ when the speedometer needle was stuck and stayed below the zero mark. After picking up my car I had driven less than a mile and the digital cluster faded to a blank screen. Immediately I went back to the shop and was told they would have to order another cluster and would call me, which they did a few days later. Now… the digital cluster won't make any warning sounds. When manually pressing on the button to test it, it shows a service visit was coming up and had the symbol to check the oil level and water pump. I was told by the tech that this is normal thing to see. That statement contradicts the car manual. I read where an authorized dealer in another state replaced the thermostat and cooling pump for a problem like this. I went back to the dealer explaining the no-alarm failure in the cluster and… Now the car has a slight jerk forward when I press the brake pedal. Strangely, the report reads: “ car ran rough, the panel lights were flashing and the car sat for a long period of time.” It also said that the transmission needed replacement and the cluster was fine. The tech told me that the car was in good shape, no alarm except for the transmission and it wasn't bad. But after getting home, the paperwork/inspection report showed that every component needed further attention. I phoned and the service advisor agreed that the technician must have made a mistake. What is your advice to get my car working properly?

Spark Plugs Replacement $96.63 - $636.71 Get a Quote
Battery Replacement $200.97 - $319.07 Get a Quote
Alternator Replacement $149.30 - $1391.75 Get a Quote
Fuel Pump Replacement $120.92 - $1186.72 Get a Quote
Car idle is rough Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote

It appears you may have a few different issues going on. It seems unlikely that more than one cluster would fail. The most likely cause is a shorted wiring or open circuit causing the clusters to fail. If the car is running roughly, there are a few potential causes, such as the spark plugs, battery, alternator, vacuum leak, or fuel pump. You may want to take this back in to have it looked at by the dealer. If you would like an independent mechanic to give this look, a certified professional from YourMechanic can come to your home or office to diagnose why your vehicle is running rough.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Car acting strange

Hi there. When you feel vibrations in multiple driving conditions, it's typically an indication of worn out motor mounts or a vacuum leak somewhere in the engine compartment. The best way to have this issue correctly diagnosed is to have...

Brakes go all the way to the floor - 1998 Buick Skylark

To eliminate the possibility of air anywhere in the hydraulic braking system, you can bleed all wheel cylinders (calipers) even if you have worked on only one. Start with the longest brake line and finish with the shortest line. That's...

Malfunction of the tire pressure monitoring system

That is a rather complex tire pressure monitoring system used by Audi. Using multiple sensors, antennae, and control module, this may require the Audi manufacturer's scan tool to communicate with in order to diagnose. A tire service center (that is...

My battery is dead and I lost my keys. What can I do. 2003 Jeep Grand Cherokee

Hello. If your battery is dead and you have lose your keys then both of these issues will need to be addressed together. The battery issue will need to be taken care of first. Either it will need to be...

My car shuts off when I turn on the light or even the turn signals please help need this car to get to work

Hi there. This type of electrical glitch can be very difficult to pinpoint or diagnose without a physical inspection. However, in general, the most common causes of this issue is an exposed electrical wire within the ignition system. It is...

Transmission acting up.

I would have the car checked out by a transmission specialist. You may have a bad shifter or shifter cable.

audi tt mk1 interior lights

It sounds like you popped a fuse. Since it happened as soon as you turned on the passenger side light, the fault may be in the light assembly. The fuse panel is accessible on the left side of the dashboard...

What does it mean if the smart key warning light comes on?

If your car has a smart key system, then it’s equipped with a warning light and buzzer that help in certain situations when the electronic key might be missing or out of range. There are several light/buzzer combinations that might...

What does the speedometer display?

There are quite a few important gauges located on the dash of your car. The speedometer is one of the most important when driving. It measures how fast your car is traveling and displays that information via a needle and...

Related articles

How to React If Your Battery Light is On
The battery light or charging warning light, available on the dashboard of your car, indicates malfunctioning or poor charging of the battery. This...
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Audi Q7
When When only the most exacting performance will do, but you want an SUV that delivers third row seating and is comfortable enough for family trips, the 2012 Audi Q7 should be on your list. Key Features While it is...
What Does the Airbag Warning Light Mean?
When the airbag warning light stays on, the airbags won't deploy for seated passengers in a collision. This could be due to a sensor issue.