Q: Overheating issue brought into dealer want to take apart engine to check head gasket

asked by on March 09, 2018

Had an overheating issue with my car so I bought a new thermostat, added coolent and bleed the system for air. Still overheating. Brought it to the dealer and after having it for a few days they’re saying I overflowed the cooling system and that it’s no longer overheating. They want to take apart my engine to see if it’s a head gasket. I asked if they ran a combustion test kit and they said they did and it was fine. Externally they don’t see an issue that’s why they want to take it apart. Don’t want to pay for 7 hours of labor if it’s not the issue???!

My car has 130000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

If the dealer is stating to you that the engine is no longer overheating, and that there are no combustion gases in the coolant, it is not clear what the problem is that they are trying to resolve by taking apart the engine. They would have to show you very specific evidence of a malfunction to justify the work. Head gaskets are not replaced as "a last report" or during any diagnostic "process of elimination". Furthermore, your engine has two cylinder heads and so there are two head gaskets. Were they proposing to remove both? If you are having a problem with the engine, and you want a specific diagnosis, that is an explanation of where the fault lies (if there is even any fault), and what the exact required repairs are, please use the request service link and the responding certified mechanic will get your situation addressed and resolved without further delay. If you have any further questions, do not hesitate to re-contact YourMechanic as we are always here to help you.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

How do I change a track with the steering wheel?

You can use the buttons on your steering wheel to toggle between songs when listening to a CD or MP3 disc. Press the up arrow on the steering wheel to go to the next track, or the down arrow to...

I have a 2005 Chevrolet Uplander, the radiator, water pump, coolant sensor and thermostat have been replaced. It still overheats w

You need to verify if the electrical cooling fan is coming on when the temperature gets up to or above normal range. if fan does not come on then this is the cause of the overheating and will need to...

Fuel pump

Fuel line quick connectors are typically used on late model GM products. These connectors have an internal o-ring and plastic clips that must be secure (verified) to be sure everything stays together. If you need connectors fabricated or supplied to...

Why does it only go 20 to 30 mph?

Hi there, thanks for writing in. First off, take your Nissan to a different mechanic. Yes; changing the motor would fix the issue, but if they are guessing that the timing chain is the reason why you're consuming as much...

codep0300 multiple misfires

Given the number of symptoms that you have described, there might be more than one basic underlying cause of the poor operation. Also, mechanical failure such as poor cylinder compression and/or sticking valves would have to be ruled out. Generally,...

I am having an issue with a 2011 Aveo where it loses power accelerating and braking/slowing down. The hard part is this is really

The possible causes of this intermittent loss of power include a faulty oxygen sensor, weak fuel pump and/or clogged filter, vacuum leaks, ignition system malfunctions, bad valve timing if the timing belt or chain is worn or skipped, blocked exhaust...

Truck stop's pulling going down highway stop put in 4wd and back to 2wd it starts back pulling

Many drivers with your same truck have had issues with the transfer case encoder motor. There will be a diagnostic trouble code (DTC) that can be retrieved with a scan tool to indicate a problem in this system. There is...

2007 GMC Yukon XL 2500. Intermittent problem with very rough engine and check engine light flashes. After a few minutes when engin

Defective ECMs are so rare that half of all warranty returns (industry-wide), once tested in a lab, turn out to be perfectly good. ECM updates (software) are another matter though. In the course of diagnosing something like this, it is...

P0420 code and engine is not starting.

Hi there. The p0420 code means that the catalytic converter is below threshold and is not functioning correctly. This code comes up when the catalytic converter can no longer burn off any fuel in the exhaust system. Take a raytech...

Related articles

The Best Used Cars to Buy If You Have Kids
Once Once you have kids, the kind of car you have becomes very important. Suddenly, the amount of space, entertainment features, reliability, safety, and easy to clean interior become the top priorities. Here’s a list of vehicles meant to satisfy...
How to Download a Chevy Owner’s Manual
When you buy a new car, you’re provided with original documents and books related to your vehicle. The materials you receive include: Your audio system operating information Your owner’s manual Your recommended maintenance schedule These manuals help...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You Live in a City
Living Living and driving in the city means you’re faced with parking constraints, narrow streets, and the constant stop and go of traffic. With all of that said when you’re ready to purchase a used vehicle these are all things...