Q: Motor failed, is it just a lemon?

asked by on November 02, 2015

The engine in my 2006 Ford Explorer failed catastrophically the other day when I was driving home from work. It started knocking, then immediately started smoking. The engine only had 66,000 miles on it, so I am really disappointed in the quality of craftsmanship from Ford. Not sure what I am going to do now. Is it even worth replacing the engine in a vehicle this unreliable already?

The engines in the Ford Explorer are either the 4.0L or the 4.6L. They have both had their share of problems and failures. First, I would have the engine checked and get an estimate of the cost to repair or replace it. Replacement with a used or a remanufactured engine is an option. You can then weigh whether it would be cost effective. I’d say it would be about the same cost to replace this engine vs buy another used Ford Explorer, but you would have a new engine and the used truck would not.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Engine revving high at idle - 2013 Infiniti JX35

Hello. You may have to have the computer reprogrammed for the idle to come down. There is a technical bulletin to reprogram the ECM or replace it if needed. Take the vehicle to the dealer to have the reprogramming done....

Car sputtering when idling

Since the check engine light is on that means that the computer is seeing a problem. I typically start by scanning the computer for codes. This will give me a starting point. From what you are saying it sounds like...

Overheating

Hi there. I would highly recommend completing a full coolant system flush first; as it's possible that you might have a few air bubbles stuck inside the cooling lines that can cause the type of overheating issue you're describing. It's...

Broke spark plug while trying to take it out

Hello. You will need to have the vehicle taken to a mechanic that has the special tool to get the broken plug out (maybe). I say maybe cause the tool may not get out the broken pieces and the cylinder...

Engine stalled, made clicking noise, made smoke

Hi there, thanks for writing in about your 2011 Mercedes E550. This sounds like potentially a bad crankshaft sensor. I would recommend having the car scanned to see which trouble codes show up.  More than likely, there will be more than...

Low RPM when on gear causes Vibration when at stopped.

Hi There, It sounds like you may have a dirty or failing idle air control valve. The idle air control valve monitors the air intake as it is mixed with fuel prior to being injected into the engine at low...

Reduced engine power

Hello there, many common problems will cause your 2009 Buick Terraza to have a loss of engine power. The most common would be spark plugs, fuel pump, coil, fuel injectors, MAF sensor, vacuum leak, oxygen sensors, or a wiring harness...

I have a 2000 ford escort zx2 2.0l vct changed the timing belt and placed it in tdc it runs rough. Where do i set it?

Your engine has a double overhead camshafts and requires special tools to hold crankshaft and camshafts in TDC position in order to get the timing correct. You may be off a tooth on the cams and will need to redo...

Transfer case making grinding noise

Hello. A grinding sound from the transfer case on this truck is an indication of an internal chain failure. This happens often on this vehicle. I will typically drain the fluid from the transfer case and see if there is...

Related articles

How to Diagnose and Repair Noisy Brakes
Squeaky car brakes are hard to drive with. If your car brakes are making noise, check the brake pads and brake rotors to see if they are worn down.
How Are Sensors Used to Improve a Car’s Performance?
Modern vehicles utilize a series of car sensors to improve performance and reduce emissions. The oxygen sensor helps reduce tailpipe emissions.
Top 10 Ways to Extend the Life of Your Car
Every driver wants a car that lasts a long time. Make your car last longer by checking your motor oil, parking in the shade, and keeping it clean.