Q: Mechanic changed cambelt and water pump and whilst returning it, it supposedly jumped off. Engine stopped dead. No more engine

asked by on October 14, 2016

My engine overheated the previous weekend for the first time. No hot air coming out of heater! Only cold. So I thought water pump and brought a new one. Phoned around to get it fitted, all garages saying I'll need a new cambelt! OK no problem. Phoned around the local garages no spaces, a friend recommended his friend who has 9yrs experience and would charge £200 to change cambelt and water pump. Picked up car and said back by the following afternoon. Got a text "on way" and need the rest of his money. As he supplied cambelt kit. Next got call car stopped and cambelt jumped off. What follows is that is its NOT HIS FAULT? He saying apparently someone previous had "helicoil" one off the pulley holes and that whilst returning the car this had failed and had made the belt jump. Now he says that none of this is his fault and that he will not charge for labour, if I pay for bits. As internal engine damage. Car at present is nearly worth less and I'm out of pocket with no driveable car.

My car has 149000 miles.
My car has a manual transmission.

Hello. I hate to say this but it is his fault. It sounds like he is not being truthful about what happened because if that was the case it would have come off well before he worked on it. It sounds to me like he installed the belt incorrectly and it came off damaging the valves of the engine. In that case he should be responsible to fix it just like any shop would at his own cost.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I play an external music player through the sound system?
If you have an external music player (such as an iPod), you can play it through your sound system. Just follow these steps. Purchase an AUX cable. Plug one end of the AUX cable into the headphone jack of your...
What does the Intelligent Key™ battery discharge indicator mean?
Your Intelligent Key™ is a critical element to operating your car, but it does require a little bit of maintenance. The most important tip for owners is to make sure the battery is replaced. Without a good battery, they key...
Broken ignition will it start if I replace the whole steering column ?
Hello there, a few different things can cause the ignition to brake. If the ignition was broken due to a theft, then the usual repair would be to replace the ignition switch (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-ignition-switch) and key cylinder (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-ignition-lock-cylinder). It would be...
How often should I change my transmission fluid
Hey there, thank you for writing in about your 2010 Chevrolet Colorado. In accordance with the schedule of your vehicle the transmission fluid and filter should be changed every 50,000 miles. If you'd like to have your transmission fluid serviced...
What are the differences with synthetic blend oil?
Hello and thank you for contacting YourMechanic. The percentage for synthetic blend oil is between 75% to 85%, depending on the manufacture. There are two types of synthetic oil (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-to-upgrade-to-synthetic-oil-by-rocco-lovetere), Semi-Synthetic and Full Synthetic. Semi-Synthetic is mixed with conventional oil...
One of the relays is clicking and draining the battery
There could be a parasitic draw involving the relay that is keeping it engaged. Lexus specifications for parasitic draw with the key off is approximately 50 milliamps. Anything over this amount indicates a parasitic draw. You could remove the fuses...
Transfer case will not lock front drive line in for 4 wheel drive.
Hi there. Sounds like the chain in the transfer case has broken. If your transfer case has gears, then the gears may have broke off or ground down the teeth. Also, the syncronizer slider in the transfer case could have...
The heat, ac, and defrost isn't blowing out the vents
Blower speed in your application is controlled by a replaceable resistor block in the blower motor circuit. If various fan speeds have become unusable, and now you are left with nothing, a possibility is all positions in this resistor block...
My battery drains itself like a ghost every now and then. Whats the problem?
Hello, thank you for writing in. The battery may be having several issues. If you have had the battery tested, and it passes all of the tests, then you are looking at parasitic draw. This is an electrical component, sensor,...

Related articles

How a Car's Cooling System Works
Have Have you ever considered the thousands of times explosions occur in your engine? If you're like most people, that thought never enters your mind. Every time a spark plug fires, the fuel and air mixture in that cylinder blows...
The Best Used Cars to Buy for Long Commutes
Most Most of us are faced with the prospect of commuting back and forth to work on a daily basis, but some have a much longer drive than others. When it comes time to buy a car, you need to...
How to Use Autostick
Autostick gives drivers with automatic transmissions the feel of a manual car. It allows the driver to upshift and downshift for extra control.