Q: Long stall between 2nd and 3rd gears, plus whining noise

asked by on September 09, 2016

When driving in the morning and I go from 2nd gear to 3rd gear, there is a long stall before the shifter will shift to 3rd. There is also a whining sound while this is happening. Pressing on the gas pedal a bit will help it to get into 3rd gear. I am thinking this might mean a new transmission is needed or perhaps I need to perform a flush. I purchased the car used, so I don’t know when the last flush was done. In your opinion, what is the problem and what will fix it? Thank you.

Hello Without having a good impression of the actual symptoms you are experiencing, it would be difficult to tell you the exact problem. I would recommend having your transmission fluid level and condition checked first. Then, if the fluid level is low or the condition is bad, have the fluid changed and see if it makes a difference. I would recommend doing this first because a fluid exchange is much more inexpensive than a transmission replacement. If the fluid exchange does not make a difference, it is possible that you may have a shift solenoid going bad for the shift between second and third gear. I would recommend having the shifting issue fully inspected by a transmission expert to determine the actual cause of your transmission issue.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Car ran out of gas

If your vehicle ran out of gas, and after adding gas it still doesn't start, you may have burned out the fuel pump. The fuel pump in most cars is housed in the gas tank. It lives submerged in the...

Shifter cable broke in heavy traffic on highway

There are a lot of inquiries regarding a similar issue with vehicles of your year and model. The linkage connection is made of plastic and will eventually break. A metal safety clip or an extra tie may be used to...

Car has hissing sound when initially accelerating

Hi there, thanks for writing in about your 2006 Porsche Cayman. Generally, a hissing noise will come from a leaking vacuum source or something like an exhaust manifold gasket. The vacuum leak will cause some performance issues as the engine...

What Are the Top Transmission Problems That Should Never Be Ignored?

Ignoring problems with cars is like ignoring problems with teeth. Waiting longer usually just results in more pain and expense. Seeing transmission fluid on the ground under your vehicle should get your attention right away. Transmission fluid is usually reddish-brown....

Car sluggish and wants to stall in 2nd gear.

Hi there. From your explanation of the problem it sounds like you are experiencing the onset of a transmission failure. A mechanic would drain the fluid from the transmission and inspect it for metal or debris in the fluid which...

What do you think about the reliability of this the 2013 Audi Q5?

Hi, thanks for writing in. As you may already know, the reliability of most vehicles depends largely on how well the car is maintained as well as the owner's driving habits, vehicle driving conditions, etc. This is especially important when...

Can a loose battery terminals cause the radio to shut off while car is running in a mecedes e350

Hi there. Typically when the vehicle is running, power to accessories and ancillary components like the AC system will be supplied by the alternator. This means that when you have inconsistent power problems like you've described, it is usually due...

My Mustang is making a squeaking/chirping sound when driving and or coasting. When I apply brakes, the sound stops. What is the problem?

Hey there. A possibility of the noise is lack of lubrication on the brake hardware. If you have rear disc brakes, it could be the pad(s) continuing to contact the rotor after you release the brakes which is due to...

Tcc solenoid broke .

Your best option is to buy a service manual; it will detail the steps required to replace the TCC solenoids. Unfortunately, YourMechanic does not work on transmissions so it may be necessary to take the car to a transmission shop,...

Related articles

How to Buy a Good Quality Transmission
When When it comes to costly parts, the transmission is right up there among the most expensive. Because of that many people opt to purchase a used transmission, which is not usually the ideal route to take. Why is that?...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You’re a Wedding Planner
As As a wedding planner, the demands placed on your time are going to be significant, even if you’re only dealing with one or two couples. You need to be a master juggler when it comes to your time and...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You're Over 50
Shopping Shopping for a car when you’re over the age of 50 begins to shift a bit, as your priorities tend to change. Suddenly it’s not so much about what the vehicle looks like, or how much space it has...