Q: Knocking Sound Run Roughly Dark Transmission Fluid and Dark Engine Oil

asked by on October 15, 2016

It's making a knocking sound coming from under the hood? Transmission oil is dark color, so should I get a transmission oil fluid change or flush? It's running rough also. Should I get a Tune up? I haven't had a tune up in a long time. What consists of getting a tune up for it (I.e. replace spark plugs)?

My car has 334456 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Air Filter Replacement $104.43 - $174.79 Get a Quote
Spark Plugs Replacement $113.11 - $716.47 Get a Quote

I am not sure how many miles your transmission has on it. I would say replace the transmission fluid but if its been more that 150,000-200,000 miles you may have to have a rebuild done on your transmission if you replace the oil. There are particles in your transmission at that point that are keeping your transmission running.

You probably do need to get a tune up including, oil change, oil filter, air filter, replace spark plugs and wires, I always suggest my customers (I do this to my vehicle faithfully also), put 1/2 can of sea foam in your engine before changing the oil. Let the engine run around 10 minutes but not more than 15 minutes. Then drain oil and replace oil filter. Do NOT drive your vehicle while sea foam is in your engine. Sea Foam will help with cleaning out sludge in your engine.

If you would like one of our professional technicians perform a tune up on your vehicle you may book one in your area at the link provided below.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Paint chipping off all over the hood and bumpers
The paint on your car is a multiple layer paint process that starts with bare metal cleaning and prep then a primer coat. The primer coat is suppose to stick well to bare metal and also allow the color coat...
What’s the range on the Intelligent Key?
Your Intelligent Key allows you to enter and exit the car, automatically unlock doors, get into the trunk and more. However, it has a limited range. In order to use the key, you need to be standing about two and...
Engine turns over good but won't start what might be the problem? It misfired one time and hasn't started since.
Your engine requires spark, air, and fuel to start and run properly. Air is almost always present so that leaves spark and fuel. Depending on the vehicle, if a crankshaft sensor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/crankshaft-position-sensor-replacement) is faulty, the engine control unit may not...
My car has trouble starting when the engine is hot, I never have a problem in the morning or when I get off work.
Hi there. It sounds like the ignition coils are getting hot and when the engine is shut off, the engine will not restart due to an ignition coil that will not produce a spark. Remove one spark plug wire at...
2013 Ford Edge 4 cyl w/ turbo Code P0299
Hi there. Although a dealership often will charge about 30% or higher than an average automotive shop, it's typically worth the extra expense; especially when an important component like the turbo is being replaced. Plus, the dealership typically warranties their...
Throttle Position Sensor
Hi There, It sounds like what you are describing is an intermittent throttle response when pressing the gas pedal. If this is correct, this may be related to the throttle position sensor. The throttle position sensor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/throttle-position-sensor-replacement) monitors the throttle...
92 nissan maxima stalling problems
You should first replace the fuel filter and see if this helps condition. If filter does not help then have fuel pressure checked to see if the fuel pump is producing enough pressure and have it replaced if below specifications....
I have a 2007 Suzuki XL7, it is constantly beeping and will not stop. I have checked everything and can't figure it out.
Hi there. In most cases, the beeping sound is created when one of two different systems creates an alert; a seat belt warning or a door is ajar. It is common for a system sensor to be damaged, which will...

Related articles

Do Cars Need Oil Changes More or Less Often As They Age?
Car engines wear out as miles add up. Older engines and engines with high mileage have lower tolerances, making more frequent oil changes necessary.
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Ford Focus Electric
In In 2012, the Ford Focus Electric model went a step farther than other eco-friendly cars. Instead of creating another hybrid model, Ford chose to offer a fully electric vehicle with a very impressive range of 76 city miles and...
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Differential Gasket
If you find traces of oil on the underside of the differential, puddles of fluid, or whining sounds, you may need to replace the differential gasket.