Q: Knocking noise. Is it a problem with the belt?

asked by on November 06, 2016

The higher the rev the faster the knocking. I found that a common problem was a bad timing belt hydraulic tensioner. I was able to remove and re-instal it without removing the usual components and covers . I gained access by only removing the passenger side tire and the two screws that hold the tensioner. There were no apparent leaks but it has an indentention at the end of the piston instead of a rounded end. I took it the a local auto parts store and compared it to a new one. There was a difference in length; about 5 millimeters. Am I correct to assume that I shouldn't have been able to reinstall it if there was tension on the belt? The car runs just fine. No dashboard alarms or check engine lights. Thanks

My car has 137000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Timing Belt Replacement $295.98 - $1425.61 Get a Quote
Idler Pulley Replacement $93.97 - $363.46 Get a Quote
Drive Belt Tensioner Replacement $134.81 - $601.33 Get a Quote

Hello - No, it is incorrect to assume that you couldn’t install the new tensioner even though it is of different length. Was the new tensioner longer or shorter? If shorter, there may not be adequate tension on the belt, and the engine could "jump time", with expensive results, especially when the belt is at the end of its service life and has stretched. Many manufacturers have introduced new tensioners over the years that improve the consistency of tension on the belt. The recommended change interval for the belt is 105K. The belt costs $40 or so, plus installation. The engine costs $4K+. If you have not changed the belt, idler pulley, as well as the tensioner, I highly recommend you do so. A certified professional from YourMechanic can come to your car’s location to perform a timing belt replacement service and any other recommended repairs at your home or office.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

I'm trying to cut my VDC líght off .and I'm pressing the button for it and it's still not cutting off

My 2016 Buick Encore is unpredictable. This morning, the check engine light and stability tracking light both lit. The engine wa

If the check engine light has illuminated, that means that trouble codes have been stored and a mechanic can download and evaluate them. Those trouble codes are undoubtedly linked to the problem you are having. Although some trouble codes can...

My seat won’t recline forward 2007 Nissan altima

If you have a non-powered seat, the cause could be mechanical in nature and involve levers and/or the seat track. If you have a powered seat, depending on exactly what you mean by "recline" the problem could be electrical and/or...

How much would a spark plug change be for a 4.6l 99 expedition? And should I change coils too?

Billing question was sent to CS for the cost to replace the spark plugs and the ignition coils on a 1999 Ford Expedition with a V8-4.6L engine.

The flex pipe needs to be replaced.

Yes, the entire section of pipe the flex pipe is attached to can be replaced. For the best fit, consider ordering the part from your local dealer. The repair may take some time depending on how much rust has built...

Are the miles too high for me to buy this car?

I would recommend checking the Kelly Blue Book Value for your car which is relevant to your particular zip code. This should give you an indication of generally what the car is worth. You will of course want to discount...

Soft knocking noise - 2003 Acura RSX

Hello. If you are getting excessive camber, you still may have lower control arm or joint wear and should be checked when you are replacing the struts that are making the knocking noise. Make sure the upper strut bearing mount...

AC wont blow on max

Based on the information you provided for your 2010 Dodge Avenger. It is likely that you have a leak in the air conditioning system. You may also have a resistor pack going bad, or the selector switch itself could be...

Rattling noise and wont go in gear

If you can put the transmission in any gear with the engine off easily but cannot get it in any gear when you start the car with the clutch in, then you have a clutch system problem. You will have...

Related articles

Why Does My AC Rattle When I Turn It On?
Common reasons why a car AC system makes a rattling noise is due to a failing AC compressor, worn serpentine belt, or worn out AC compressor clutch.
Why Timing Belts Have Teeth and How They Work
Timing Timing belts are used in any number of mechanical devices, but you most often think of this type of toothed belt in connection with your car or truck, where it serves to drive the camshaft. The original timing belts...
Symptoms of Bad or Failing Stabilizer Bar Links
Common signs of faulty stabilizer bar links include clunking or rattling noises from the tire area, poor handling, and a loose steering wheel.