Q: Extreme power loss, engine rattling.

asked by on August 01, 2016

Hi, my post is about a 2008 BMW 523i... The car is very low mileage (43000km/26000mi). I didn't have it at the time, however the oil level was showing low and hence my father who had it borrowed at the time filled it up with one litre, just to last until it got its oil change. About one week later, the car lost power (SUPER slow acceleration, the engine light is on;), also when it revs over 2.5k rpm this weird, rattling sound can be heard. (it didn't do this at first) Since, I've had the ECU repaired as apparently it was faulty, and one injector replaced as the diagnostics were throwing these codes. These have disappeared after the fix, but the problem persists. Mechanic told me that it's likely a loose timing chain. Could adding 15W-40 instead of 5W30 create this issue? Does my (brief) description sound like that could really be it, and what needs to be repaired if it really is a loose timing chain? Does it need to be completely replaced? Thanks... :/

My car has 26000 miles.
My car has a manual transmission.

Change Oil and Filter $92.43 - $157.60 Get a Quote
Loss of power Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote

Using 15w-40 instead of 5w-30 could be the cause of your problem. Your engine has very small passages that lead to the valve train. One components in particular, hydraulic lifters, require a good flow of oil through a small passage to be able to properly function. 15/w-30 is a thicker oil than the engine is designed to use.

By using this thicker oil, oil flow through the small passages slows down. With the flow of oil slower, the lifter can’t properly operate. The result is that your intake and exahust valves will not open fully and at higher RPM’s, there is not enough flow to maintain the designed clearances between certain parts of the valve train.

The rattle you hear may be caused by this lack of oil flow, and your loss of power may be a by-product of your valves not fully opening. I would suggest a full oil change as a first step, making sure to use the oil specified by BMW. If you are still having problems, a complete engine diagnosis will be in order to determine the exact cause of the loss of power.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Pontiac G6 GT intermittently jerking on acceleration with no check engine light

Hi Jennifer. The most common cause of this type of problem is a damaged mass air flow sensor. The mass airflow sensor measures how much air is entering the engine and relays this information to the vehicle’s computer so the...

Fuel Pump Malfunction

In October 2016, BMW announced a recall covering fuel pumps for certain models produced during model years 2007-2012. Your vehicle appears to be outside the scope of this recall but nevertheless it would be a good due diligence to contact...

Car not starting after jumpstart

It sounds like your starter motor may have failed. I would recommend having your battery fully charged then load tested to ensure it functions properly. Once the battery is known to be good, have it reinstalled and try to start...

EWS code

The EWS (Electronic Immobilizer) light on your BMW is an alarm that will cause your car to not start. Something you can attempt is using a different key to start your BMW. If after trying a different key, the car...

Low beam doesn't work due to water damage

The lighting system on this vehicle is computer controlled through a smart control box in the passenger compartment on the left side of a pilar. The water in the light could of shorted the module and burned out the module...

OBD Code for Transmission Fluid Temperature Sensor in CD4E transmission, can't find any info on parts or part number or location

The transmission fluid temperature sensor is part of the transmission hardware unit on top of the transmission. It is replaced as part of the whole component.

Car slipping out of gear

Hello! With the transmission slipping, this vehicle is not safe to drive until this issue is resolved. The most common causes of the transmission slipping is low or improper transmission fluid level, or internal failures in the transmission. A qualified...

Attempted to change oil filter, but the oil filter cap broke, the top half of cap is broken off, the threaded part still remains.

Hi, thanks for writing in. I would proceed to carefully continue with the hammer and chisel. You could also try using a punch with the hammer to try and spin it out. The sudden shock from the punch could help...

Heater is running cold, engine light is on, rough idle

Hello there, many faults will cause your heat to blow cold and check engine light on with your 2007 Honda CRV. The first step in diagnosis would be to check what code your car has stored in the computer, this...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 BMW X5
The The 2012 BMW X5 is an SUV that offers both utility and ease of driving. The steering is responsive with a good amount of horsepower. If you are looking for a sportier SUV that offers versatility, the BMW X5...
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 BMW 5-Series
BMW BMW has built a reputation for refined engineering, powerful performance and excellent fit and function. That’s exactly what you’ll find with the 2012 BMW 5-Series sedans. Composed and powerful, they provide a range of price points, features and capabilities...
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 BMW 7-Series
When When power, performance and luxury are at the top of your list, the 2012 BMW 7-Series is sure to be a perfect fit. From the stylish design to two length options for enhanced comfort, three available engines and two...