Q: Engine shaking and strange noise from the engine bay, also weird rpm at start up

asked by on June 16, 2016

My car is a 2004 VW Golf Mk5 (1.4 Fsi, european), petrol, 130 000 km, and I just bought it 2 weeks ago from a dealer. A few days ago I started to notice that when I start up with 1st shift on (and i think Reverse as well), the engine works at ~1000 rpm. When I start the engine at Neutral, it works at ~650 rpm, and i feel the engine shaking and making something like a knock sound on the back of the engine. When stopping at red lights, with 1st gear and clutch depressed, it also goes back to 650 rpm and I feeling the same shaking. I would love some help here, because I want to have some ideas of what may be causing this, before taking it to the dealer just to hear a "ok, this is a completely normal situation". Thank you very much for your help.
My car has a manual transmission.

Hello there, a few possible items can cause a similar noise to what you describe. Most likely it is an engine misfire, fuel pump problem, worn out fuel filter, dirty idle air valve (which you may be able to clean), or an oxygen sensor. I’d start by examining these components and trying the tips outlined in the linked articles. If you still need help, a qualified technician such as one from YourMechanic will be able to diagnose this fault and perform any repairs required.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

How do I use the seat heaters?
If your car is equipped with seat heaters (optional equipment), they provide an additional solution of comfort during cold weather, as well as for easing an aching back. Using them is actually very simple. Here’s what you need to know:...
Recommendation on most reliable cars
One thousand dollars for a car is not much these days. I have a '94 Toyota Celica I'm driving and I paid 350 bucks for it five years ago. However, I bought it from a customer of mine who was...
I hear a clink sound when I put my car in reverse
My guess is that you have a bad transmission mount or motor mount (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-long-do-engine-motor-mounts-last). You probably noticed this more when the engine is cold because the idle is higher. A trained professional, such as one from YourMechanic, will be able...
Switched to synthetic oil, now I smell burning oil, possibly engine running hotter
Hi, thanks for writing in. Synthetic oil (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/can-you-switch-between-regular-and-synthetic-motor-oil) is typically a little bit thinner than conventional oil. Often times when a vehicle is switch from conventional to synthetic this can cause oil leaks or burning oil. I would recommend changing...
Where is the thermostat location for a 2013 Chrysler 200 2.4L
Hello, the thermostat on this engine is located at the "rear" (driverside of the car) of the cylinder head. It is somewhat covered up by the valve and cam housings above it, and is fairly difficult to access. There is...
ford focus mk2 2.0 car idle rough and have no power.change.put feet on brake padel-car goes limp mode. 2005 Ford Focus
Hello - check first for problem codes, whether the Check Engine light is illuminated or not. The change in rough running behavior (https://www.yourmechanic.com/question/suv-experienced-low-acceleration-and-loss-of-power) when you press the brake pedal may indicate a failed brake booster. A ruptured diaphragm in the...
I hear a slight knock that doesn't get louder when you accelerate
Hello there. Knocking in your engine, also described as pinging, can mean one of several problems. Some may be easily fixed while others may indicate major damage. The knocking sound often occurs when the fuel and air mixture is incorrect,...
2.5l Nissan sentra manual, car will run fine for about 15 minutes then will not rev while in gear, will rev when in neutral
It could be an issue in the throttle control system: throttle body, or accelerator position sensor. But there are some basic checks that need to be done before you start replacing parts. The first thing to check for in any...
replaced automatic transmission on 04 outback H6. All done, but no action from starter what so ever. Battery is fully charged.
Check for battery voltage to the push on terminal on the starter solenoid with the key held in the start position. If the heavy gauge starter positive cable has no voltage drop, and there is battery voltage to the solenoid...

Related articles

A Buyer's Guide to the 2012 Volkswagen Beetle
Although Although it may be one of the most recognizable cars on the road, thanks to its unique design, perhaps you’ve never considered owning a Volkswagen Beetle before. There are a number of reasons the 2012 model should have you...
The Top 5 Selling Cars in Connecticut in 2012
Connecticut Connecticut offers plenty of rain and its fair share of snow during the winter months, which means drivers need vehicles that can handle these conditions. Top selling vehicles in previous years have included the Toyota Camry, Corolla and the...
Top Automotive News & Stories – September 3-9
This week's top auto news: Ford's 3D printed future, Dieselgate guilty plea, Toyota Supra prototype spied, LaFerrari Aperta on the road, and more.