Q: Engine has sludge.

asked by on January 14, 2016

My engine has sludge in it. The dealer says the engine needs to be replaced. Can sludge be removed? If so, what is the cost? If not, what is the cost of replacing an engine?

Engine oil is black and gritty Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote

Replacing an engine is a very costly repair. Oil sludge often results from contaminated or neglected oil. Not having oil changed at regular specified maintenance intervals will cause sludge to build up inside the engine. Sludge if not excessive can be removed via an oil system flush. A flush consists of a detergent additive that is run through the engine oiling system and these detergents break down the sludge and then the oil system is drained. Unfortunately, though once excessive oil sludge develops in the engine lubricated engine parts become starved of oil and premature wear of components and failure often occurs. Before replacing an engine though I would recommend a second opinion by a mechanic, such as one from YourMechanic, who can determine if a flush can save the engine or if an engine replacement is going to be the only option.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Noisy when I go over bumps, ride isn’t smooth

The manufacturer shocks in the rear and the struts in the front do not seem to last very long before getting noisy or causing poor ride conditions. This seems to be a very common issue with other owners also. Many...

2008 Kia Sedona, 3.8L V-6, transverse : check engine light constant on; occasional random misfire(P0300) with P2198

If you are getting random misfire codes and O2 sensor codes after getting fuel i suggest you have a fuel sample test to see if there is excessive water in the fuel. You can try adding some drygas in the...

Engine skipping.

The skipping you are feeling is the engine misfiring. Your engine coils, plugs and plug boots may need replaced. The valve covers may also be leaking oil into the spark plug holes and the cause of the miss fire. I...

How do I view the engine oil life?

The engine oil life is a feature that shows you how much life is left in your current batch of engine oil. To view the engine oil life, press the SER/Reset button until the information display shows the engine oil...

Adding a lot of oil between changes, no signs of a leak

You have not provided specific amounts of oil you have added per 1000 miles you drove. To do a proper diagnosis of your oil consumption claim, you would have to do an oil consumption test. This test is done by...

Where is the fuel filtet located on 2008 Kia Rondo LXV6

The fuel filter on your Rondo is actually located inside the fuel tank and is part of the fuel pump assembly. We could make some suggestions on what else could be causing the issues, if we had a little more...

2004 Hyundai Santa Fey with rebuilt engine locked up

I definitely would bring the car back to the shop that rebuilt your engine to have them repair it. If the engine is locked up, it is locked up because something is broken internally, like a piston, rod, or a...

My Dodge Avenger is running hot intermittently. New thermostate, coolant has been flushed for air pockets.

A scan tool should be applied to measure the actual engine operating temperature. Gauge and/or temperature sensor/sending unit malfunctions have to be ruled out. if the car is in fact overheating, a plugged radiator, a faulty radiator pressure cap, collapsed...

Clutch vs. Master/Slave Cylinder?

This sounds like you have a problem with the clutch. The clutch is slipping causing the rpm to rev high and the car to not move. The clutch disc can be slipping due to it being worn or fluid getting...

Related articles

What is a Compression Test?
A compression test will reveal the state of your engine’s parts, and can potentially save you money on buying a replacement engine.
What Is the Difference Between Regular and Synthetic Motor Oil?
Regular and synthetic motor oils each have their own benefits. Choosing the right oil for your engine depends on your car's age and how you drive.
How to Troubleshoot a Car Exhaust or Engine Noise
Car exhaust systems and car engines make whirring, clicking, or sputtering noises if there's a faulty belt, alternator, water pump, or tension pulley.