Q: 2009 Subaru Forester Runs Rough

asked by on March 05, 2017

Hi,

My wife's Subaru has been at the shop for months. It runs rough and we don't know why.

Here's what he has done: Full oil change and filter replacement, Tire rotation, Brake inspection, cleaning and adjustment, leveling of all fluids, Full battery, starter and charging system check up (battery replaced), checked all lights and wiper blades, A/C system check, throttle pedal replacent (electronic pedal), Spark plug replacement, Fuel fuel pump replacement (complete pump assembly), Electronic EGR valve replacement, VVTI valves, cleaned and inspected, In line fuel pressure regulator bypassed to increase fuel pressure (fuel pressure regulator re installed),

This is all I have done to the vehicle. Fault still persists. Car has rough start and will idle poorly. Once warmed up engine will idle rough and only even out above 3500 rpms.

We live on a small Caribbean island and it's the European version of 2.0 gas engine.

It has 60000 miles and an automatic transmission.

Car idle is rough Inspection $79.99 - $99.99 Get a Quote

There are numerous potential causes for your concern. Your vehicle has electronic throttle control, as you mentioned. In this system, a stepper motor integrated into the throttle body is used to control throttle position. The main inputs for throttle control include signals from the accelerator position sensor, which you already had replaced, and the throttle position sensor (integrated into the throttle body). A problem with the electronic throttle system could be cause of your concern. The issue could also be vacuum leak somewhere in the system. These are just two possibilities. For a definitive answer, the vehicle will need to be diagnosed firsthand by a professional, such as one from YourMechanic.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $65/hr

What others are asking

Driver's side low beam light is dim, even after replacing the bulb.

Did you see any corrosion or a broken connector on the dimmer side? Corrosion can build up in the circuit and rod the bulb of voltage causing a dim light. A technician with access to a wiring diagram can trace...

Idler pulley for surpentene belt fell off

Hello. If the bolt is gone then it either broke or loosened. If it simply fell out then the bracket is fine. I usually check the bracket hole to make sure that the threads are still there. If the threads...

Fuel gauge not accurate

The fuel gauge on the dashboard receives a signal from sensors in the gas tank. Some models of your vehicle have multiple sensors and both have to be working properly for an accurate fuel level. An experienced technician, such as...

Parasitic battery drain

When trying to locate the draw on a battery, I would normally use a process of elimination to locate where the draw(s) is coming from. With everything off, and measuring the draw, I would begin pulling individual fuses or relays....

Car shakes violently and 'check engine' flashes

Since you are only getting a misfire on cylinder number 3 specifically, this informs me that the cylinder ignition is not the problem. Since the engine has a coil pack that powers two cylinders at the same time and if...

Truck runs really rough, smells like antifreeze in the cabin, testing said it was O2 sensor, and there is an overheating, hissing noise

Hello. You can possibly rent a cooling system pressure tester from a local chain auto parts store. With the engine off, remove the radiator cap and pump the cooling system to no more than 10 psi. You will be able...

Has a rough idle with no CEL on

I would try and have the fuel injectors and throttle body cleaned out. This should clean out injectors and intake valve carbon deposits that can cause the rough idle. If after driving the vehicle, and the CEL comes on, then...

I have a 2003 Subaru Forester and upon starting this morning it ran fine for a minute or two. Then the Check Engine Light came on.

Too much air flowing into the intake causes the engine to lean out too much air in relation to the fuel and misfire. At an idle, the PCV valve restricts air flow, to reduce this problem. At high manifold vacuum...

When moving the shifter in reverse, it won't engage

Yes, your description is that of a common problem. The issue usually results from a clutch being out of adjustment. The adjustment that you likely need is known as the clutch actuator adjustment. To adjust the clutch, the technician must loosen...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2013 Subaru BRZ
This This sports car for the everyday man or woman is an irresistible combination of style, handling, and just plain fun. The BRZ offers a respectably good time on the way to work or on the way around the race...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You're a Dog Breeder or Trainer
These These days, dogs are more and more likely to travel with people than ever before. After all, what dog doesn’t ride in a car? As a breeder and trainer though, you’re probably more likely to carry along dogs than...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You Just Had a Baby
Having Having a baby will completely change your life. Your activities and hobbies will change. Your sleeping patterns will change. Chances are good that you’ll also be looking for a change in vehicles. You need to ensure that your car...