Q: Car damaged by garage

asked by on December 02, 2016

I recently put my car in for repairs. New waterpump rocker cover gasket. The garage has damaged the ecu by not disconnecting the battery before undertaking the repairs. That's what they are telling me. They have had the carry going on 3 weeks now. I'm just wondering how serious this is for the car?

My car has 100000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

I can comment on the need for the ecu, without knowing if they in fact damaged it or not. I can say that it is possible to damage any vehicle electronics when working on or near any power source such as the battery or alternator. If a positive (+) power source such as the positive battery cable, positive connection at the alternator, etc, are grounded in any manner, such as contacting them with a tool while another part of the tool is contacting the engine for example, that can cause a short-to-ground. Most vehicle electronic functions and sensor input or output, are controlled by the ecu controlling their ground (-). A short-to-ground can have that voltage spike run through any electronic component, including the ecu. If the ecu is damaged or shorted, the vehicle will run poorly or not at all. If that’s the case, the only solution is to replace the ecu to restore proper function to the vehicle.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Car overheated and now it's shutting off. It cranks but won't start.

Hi there. If the coolant leaks out too much, the computer will see this from the coolant temperature and coolant level sensors and shut off the engine to prevent any damage to the engine. Check for the coolant leaks and...

What side is my starter on a 2006 nissan pathfinder

Hello, thank you for writing in. The starter is tucked up behind the oil pan towards the right side of the vehicle. The right side is also known as the passenger side of the vehicle. There should be two mounting...

Dynamic Stability Control light on and stuck in 3rd gear

There is likely a wheel speed sensor issue causing the DSC light to be on. It also sounds like your transmission is in "limp' mode - being stuck in 3rd gear. The problem codes, and professional interpretation, will provide more...

My radiator fan only turns on when my AC turns on.

Hello there, a couple of different items can cause the fan to not work like this. The most likely culprits are a thermostatic switch, fan resistor, temperature switch, low-speed or high-speed relay, or a wiring issue. If the vehicle overheats,...

My BMW can't go over 5 mph

Your car has an electronic throttle motor, which opens the throttle when you step on the accelerator. It's possible that the throttle is not activating with the pedal. A problem like that should be accompanied by a check engine or...

What are the signs and symptoms of a leaking rack and pinion?

Motor vehicle safety inspections in almost all U.S. jurisdictions do not cover maintenance and ordinary wear and tear, including de minimus "leaks", unless the "defect" found creates an immediate, obvious, and direct impact on the safety of the vehicle or...

Why did my 'E' brake and battery light came on at same time?

The battery light will come on when the event that the battery is no longer being charged. The 'E' brake (parking brake) light comes on when the fluid is low in the master cylinder or there is a pressure difference...

Horn stays on

Based on the information you provided, it sounds like you have a short in the horn's wiring. It may be at the steering wheel but could also be elsewhere. Electrical tests will be able to confirm the location of the...

Starting and no power and check engine light

If I understand correctly, it sounds as though you're having difficulty starting your car and that you have read a code for the crank position sensor. A crank position sensor is a common failure in your car and can cause...

Related articles

Ten Sports Cars That Double as Good Daily Drivers
The best daily driver is a car that's reliable, usable, and still fun to drive. Popular daily sports cars include the BMW M3, Subaru WRX, and VW GTI.
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 BMW 1-Series
The The 2012 BMW 1-Series, which includes both the 128i and the 135i in both a coupe and convertible options, provides the perfect combination of power, performance and luxury. Designed with a focus on thrilling acceleration and a smooth, elegant...
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 BMW X6
The The X6 is a study in identity crises. While the sleek fastback styling and cozy interior suggest a sporty coupe, the hatchback and SUV platform speak to a weak attempt at imitating a wagon (without the roomy passenger capacity)....