Q: What is the truth about brake rotors/brake jobs?

asked by on September 19, 2016

I'm hearing a lot of what sounds like baloney about the REQUIREMENT of replacing rotors every time the pads are changed. Can you give me some like the truth on this subject? Everyone I have spoken too gives the appearance of lying through their collective teeth.

My car has 55000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Brake Pads Replacement $125.62 - $449.32 Get a Quote
Brake Rotor/Disc Replacement $227.65 - $1080.24 Get a Quote

Hello. The rotors on most cars have a minimum thickness that they can be before they should be replaced. The minimum thickness is stamped into the rotor. The rotor can then be resurfaced until it gets too thin and should be replaced. Other reasons the rotor should be replaced are purple heat marks on the rotor and stress cracks. A rotor surface should be at least scuffed up if it is not being replaced or it is not warped. This non-directional scuffing will allow the new pads to seat in properly to the old rotor. The reason most mechanics recommend rotors with new pads is most vehicles will have too thin of rotors, warped rotors, heat or stress cracked rotors. The mechanic is liable to do the brake job correctly to prevent unsafe conditions. If you would like to have this done, a qualified mechanic can perform a brake pads and rotors repair (if necessary) at your home or office.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Stuttering at idle at regular intervals of about 7 seconds on a 1997 Honda Civic

Yes, it is typical on those Hondas. First, watch my video "How to Fix a Car that Idles Poorly." Take off the air intake, then duct the rubber part that goes to the intake on the top of the engine...

2012 chrysler 200 won't start after replacing alternator which was bad after testing.

Hi there. It sounds like something may have shorted during the alternator replacement. If the positive cable going to the alternator made contact with anything metal, then it may have blown the main fuse. If not, then the battery should...

How do I safely park while towing a trailer?

Parking your car with a trailer attached can be tricky. It’s not as simple as finding a spot and putting the car in park. You need to follow a few important steps: Find a parking spot long enough to...

Power steering leak

Power steering leaks are not uncommon. There are a few places the power steering fluid can leak from: hoses, steering rack, and power steering pump. Getting the power steering leak diagnosed and repaired quickly would be in your best interest....

Warning: Engine Malfunction! Reduced Power: Engine is operating at reduced output

This is a sign of your car's automatic fail safe mode. When your car's computer detects that something has gone wrong in one of it's major systems, it will send the car into what is known as a "limp mode"...

How do I cancel the security alarm system?

The security alarm system will be automatically canceled any time a key or remote transmitter is used to unlock the doors, or when a key is used to turn the vehicle on.

My Check Engine Light came on 2 days after we replaced our battery

The Check Engine Light may or may not be related to the battery change on any late-model car like this one - even a simple operation like changing a battery is not so simple. There are a number of settings...

Squeaking noise when braking. Pads still very good.

The majority of modern cars on the road have certain wear marks in the brake pads that will make a squeaking noise when they reach a specific material thickness. When the pads wear down to a specific mark, they will...

I changed the brake pads recently, there is now a knocking sound when applying the brakes

You are hearing the brake pads moving up and back in the caliper bracket. This is caused by the front rotors being warped, and it is also possible that the pads' anti-rattle clips were not installed correctly. The rotors should...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Jeep Patriot
Those Those who love getting off road will often turn to a Jeep. The 2012 Patriot could be a good choice for those who want a quality vehicle for the roads, and when they decide to venture off the beaten...
A Buyer's Guide to the 2012 Lincoln MKX
As As far as midsize SUVs go, the 2012 Lincoln MKX is one of your best options out there. Considering its price, Lincoln packed this vehicle with a ton of power and luxury. Although it bears a strong resemblance to...
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Audi Q7
When When only the most exacting performance will do, but you want an SUV that delivers third row seating and is comfortable enough for family trips, the 2012 Audi Q7 should be on your list. Key Features While it is...