☰
GET A QUOTE

Q: What causes rear suspension damaged out of sudden without hitting on anything, accident nor high speed bump?

asked by on June 22, 2016

I rented a BMW 4 series and the rear suspension damaged out of sudden on the 4th day of our trip. After investigation, the rental company concluded that is our fault saying that they confirm the broken piece was only damaged as a result of this recent impact. So, we need to compensate a very high price because of that. Seriously, I couldn't accept the result because I was driving with care and didn't hit on anything. I don't understand why is this BMW so fragile? Anything I can do to defense for myself regarding this issue? Thanks if you able to provide me some advice here :)

My car has 26657 miles.

Save Big on Auto Repairs Get a Quote

The only common issue I found for the rear suspension is that the rear axle joints are prone to failure. Other than that problem there are no recalls or bulletins for anything else. If the problem was an axle then it may be due to a defective part. My best advise is to have them show you the broken part and take pictures of the damage.

BMW
Renting
2015
L4-2.0L Turbo
suspension
428i
The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Heater doesn’t really work
If your car is not overheating and has the proper amount of antifreeze in the system, then your problem is most likely caused by a problem with the temperature blend door. The blend door failure can cause your temperature control...
Read more
What precautions should I take with the air bag system?
While the air bags in your car are designed to enhance safety during accidents, you do need to take a few precautions to ensure that you don’t damage the system, or increase your risk of injury. Here’s what you should...
Read more
Car will not shift into gears above 2nd gear.
Hello, your transmission is electronically controlled so there can be a different problem with the same outcome. There is a transmission control unit that controls two electronic solenoids that control fluid flow to the valve body. Your transmission has solenoids...
Read more
Making strange noise while accelerating and decelerating.
When you observe noise coming from your engine, it can be a startling event. Without a mechanic’s ear to listen, it can be hard to pinpoint exactly what you are hearing. Luckily we can narrow down these noises based on...
Read more
Slight resistance when driving forward, ABS light is on.
I would have a mechanic check it out to determine why your ABS light is on (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/abs-light-is-on-inspection). They can check ABS codes with a scan tool to determine the problem. It may be a bad wheel speed sensor.
Read more
Needs to pass smog check..
If the check engine light is only coming on when your on the freeway it might be a problem that the computer is only recognizing at cruising speeds. Your best bet would be to have a certified mechanic read the...
Read more
How do I turn on the cargo light?
The cargo light provides extra light to your trunk area. To turn on the cargo light, press the Cargo Light switch, directly next to the light. Press the switch again to turn off the light. Tips If the trunk is...
Read more
Broken timing belt
Installing a new engine will obviously solve the problems related to the timing belt damage (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-timing-belt). As for the question of more problems, this is not really something that can be guaranteed, although I would recommend checking into the warranty...
Read more
Where can I rent a gojack? It's a self unloading jack dolly. It would hacve to fit 30 inch wheels, open at 28 inches
Hi there. It really depends on where you live. Some equipment companies like Ahern rentals offer these products. I would complete a local Google search to locate a company that offers these type of rentals.
Read more

Related articles

Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Air Suspension Air Compressor
If your car is riding lower than usual, making abnormal sounds, and its compressor won't start, you may need to replace the air suspension compressor.
Read more
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Suspension Air Bag
Common signs include the rear feeling loose or spongy, a bouncy or rough ride, the air compressor running frequently, and sagging on one side.
Read more
How to Get the Best Rental Car for the Lowest Price
When you need to rent a car (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/how-to-rent-a-car-if-you-re-only-going-one-way-by-jason-unrau), you would like to get the best value for money. The least expensive car on the car rental agency’s lot usually has the fewest features and may not be the most comfortable...
Read more

Browse other content

Cars
Estimates
Cities
Maintenance