Q: Too Much ATF?

asked by on October 16, 2016

I looked under my hood to check my stuff out and I check my dip stick for my ATF and a tiny bit of smoke was coming out of the tube where I put the dipstick. And on top of that my car makes a low/soft grind noise when shifting gears and it made me worry, so I took it to a shop in my city where I've gotten most to all of my other work done on my car and I explained to him what was happening and he told me that the reason behind the smoking was that I have too much ATF in my transmission and that I would need to get it drained and replaced. My question is that is that the actual problem that I'm having? Where my fluid should be and where it's at isnt much of a difference. MAYBE like an inch. And if so, when I get the ATF taken out and replaced will the grinding noise and the smoke problems go away and will it ride normal? Also, since I do not know how long the overfilled fluid has been like that, how do I go about finding out what other damage has been done because of the overfilled ATF

My car has 70150 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Grinding noise while shifting Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

Hello. The shop you took the car too is absolutely correct. Your transmission is like your brain, if anything goes into it that may be foreign will fail. Your engine is like your body. You can add things to it and it will slow down but will still function. So too much fluid will cause your transmission to make noises and not drive properly and also blow seals and gaskets inside of your transmission. Will it fix everything, no one can be sure. My suggestion would be to drain your fluid until it is at the correct level. Take your car for a test drive and hopefully it fixes those problems. Note - When you do check you transmission fluid ALWAYS have the engine on but when you fill it have it off. If you need help getting a more precise diagnosis, a qualified professional from YourMechanic can come to your car’s location to inspect the shifting noise and advise you on the correct repair.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Car weak when starting
If the vehicle sounds weak when you turn the key, as in it cranks slowly, or struggles to turn over, then it is most likely a battery or starter issue. I would have the battery load tested to make sure...
tranny mount or solenoid
I watched your video and unfortunately it doesn't give me the information I need. I do like the initiative though. In the future, which will be hard to record, I need to hear what the motor sounds like in the...
My car shuts off while driving
Hello. Engine stalling can be caused by a wide variety of issues. Faults within the fuel, ignition, or engine management systems can all cause the vehicle to experience stalling. A few common causes of stalling are a bad idle air...
car wont start after changing crank shaft pulley
This sounds like potentially either a loose crankshaft pulley bolt or potentially stripped threads on this bolt. Either way, this has likely caused a problem with timing (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/adjust-ignition-timing) and potentially a variety of other issues. Since you can't get the...
My Kia Forte is making a grinding knocking noise when I put it in drive and accelerate and at about 5 mph and up it goes away unti
Hello. Exhaust systems can make a variety of sounds that we would not intuitively expect. When I was first learning about exhaust systems I was surprised to find out how dynamic they can be. I am assuming you are speaking...
what do i need to do when my tire pressure, electric steering and vehicle stability lights come on
Due to the impact of another vehicle hitting your car, there may be several things wrong that may or may not be visible such as the wheel speed sensors (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/wheel-speed-sensor-replacement). Your car is equipped with wheel speed sensors at each...
Is my gas meter broken?
This may be a result of a faulty fuel tanks sending unit. There is a small float type unit inside your fuel tank that monitors the fuel level inside the tank. When this is not working properly, this can cause...
I have a clunking and popping noise when turning
This is a common sign of a failing CV joint. A CV (Constant Velocity) joint is a shaft that connects the transmission to the wheels, essentially transferring the power from the drive train directly to the wheels. The CV joint...
Entire bank1 misfires, and lower compression. 1997 BMW 540
Hi there - yes, it is possible to have cam timing (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/why-timing-belt-replacements-can-be-tricky-by-marvin-sunderland) for one cylinder bank off after a timing chain component repair. Way too easy actually with this engine! If you did not loosen the cam sprocket to cam...

Related articles

Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Front Output Shaft Bearing
Common signs include a noisy drivetrain, excessive vibrations, and oil leaking from the transfer case in all-wheel or four-wheel vehicles.
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Transmission Position Sensor (Switch)
Common signs include the car not starting or moving, transmission going into a different gear than selected, and the vehicle going into limp mode.
How Long Does a Kickdown Cable Last?
In In order for a car to run smoothly, the engine and the transmission will have to work together. With all of the different components in the engine and transmission of a car, keeping up with them all can be...