Q: rough idle on start up everytime

asked by on August 10, 2016

2003 BMW 318i 2.0. Car would take 3-4 tries to start up and then immediately stall if i didn't keep the revs consistent and between 1 and 2.5k. There would be loss in power while driving.

Parts changed to try and cure (btw no EML light and nothing on diagnostics):

  • EXH and INLT camshaft sensors
  • EXH and INLT solenoids
  • Timing chain tensioner (old one was 5mm shorter)
  • Full service

Timing chain was inspected with rocker cover off - was fine Car has only covered a genuine 58k miles

Rocker cover gasket was replaced about a year and a half ago due to smoke coming out of where the EXH manifold but this problem is still present whenever the car starts up.

All parts are from BMW dealer so this problem has cost me a lot so far.

So after these parts replaced. The car starts up first time but again have to keep revs over 1k otherwise it will stall. After keeping revs consistent and letting the car warm up for 10 minutes. The idling levels normally and then it drives fine with no fault.

My car has 58020 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Car is hard to start Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote
Car is stalling Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

You could have several things contributing to the hard start. Dirty or faulty throttle valve, idle air control valve, bad temperature sensor, and more. I suggest having a certified technician, like one from YourMechanic, perform a few tests to be able to diagnose the exact cause of your stalling issue.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Engine bogs down
The ignition timing (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/what-does-ignition-timing-mean) may have jumped, causing the timing to be off. The ignition timing will need to be checked to see if the camshaft timing jumped. If the timing is not the cause, then check to see if...
My car cuts off when I slow down and shows code P0335
Hi there. Your vehicle shutting down while driving, after replacing a faulty CKP (crankshaft position sensor) and the ECM (engine control module) recognizing a P0335 circuit malfunction, leads me to believe the replacement CKP sensor may be faulty (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/crankshaft-position-sensor-replacement). Sometimes,...
Car won't start after sitting for 14 months
Hi there. Check the fuel pump to see if it is energizing, and check the fuel pump relay (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/fuel-pump-relay-replacement) to see if it is clicking when you turn on the key. If the relay is not clicking, then remove the...
Wobbling or vibrating noise from the front
Hi there. Diagnosing a vibration sound is very difficult to do remotely, which is why most mechanics will test drive your vehicle first to attempt to replicate the sound you're experiencing. However, in most cases, the type of sound you're...
Popping sound while idling.
Hi there. One or more of the drive belt pulleys may be bent causing the engine to have erratic rpm's when at idle and causing the engine to stall out at times. Open the hood with the engine running and...
Ignition
Hi there. Unfortunately, we're not able to post images in the Q & A; which is why purchasing a service and repair manual for your Honda Odyssey would be very helpful in explaining how the ignition system works and is...
if a mechanic said he replaced your wheel bearings would it be worse 5 days later
It could be that the wheel bearing was damaged during installation. or it could be that the noise was mis-diagnosed and replacing the wheel bearing didn't solve the problem. There are many stories about mechanics charging for work that was...
My truck keeps havi,g reduced engine power and saying service stability track,and traction control off. What could this be
You may have problem with the transmission or throttle control and will need to have the computer tested for fault codes that will point to the possible fault and lead to further testing to pinpoint the cause. You may have...
I have a 93 Lexus LS400, I put a power steering pump on it yesterday and I'm still getting a whining noise .
It sounds like you may have a power steering rack that may be putting too much strain on the power steering pump causing it to leak or fail. The rack and pinion gear set does two things: It converts the...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2011 BMW X6 ActiveHybrid
This This “Sports Activity Vehicle” – a moniker bestowed by its maker – is one of those few cars that toes the line between SUV, hatchback sedan, and a just plain quirky car. Regardless of its true identity, however, the...
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Battery Temperature Sensor
Common signs include engine surging, low battery voltage, and an illuminated Battery Light.
BMW Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) Car Program
Shopping Shopping for a used BMW vehicle often leads many drivers to consider certified pre-owned options. BMW is one of many manufacturers that have a certified pre-owned (CPO) program. Each car manufacturer structures their CPO program differently; read on to...