Q: My brake pedal's soft and the car's braking system is in good shape, so what can it be?

asked by on October 11, 2016

For the past month, I've noticed that the brake pedal in my car is much softer than usual, not at all as firm as it normally is (or was), and that I'm having to depress the pedal further to get the car to stop.

All rotors and brake pads have been replaced within the past three years, and I've taken it to three separate auto shops who cannot find anything wrong with the braking system, or at least nothing that's apparent to them.

So my question is: Where would you look/what would you try to do in this situation when three separate routine brake inspections have yielded no results?

My car has 147000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

First, I would road test the vehicle to verify there is a problem. Then I would check the parking brake is adjusted up tight. A loose adjusted parking brake means the rear brakes are out of adjustment. The parking brake should start to engage after the third or forth click when lifting handle slowly.

I would then remove all four wheels and check the brakes for problems with the brake lines, caliper slides, rotors, calipers and pads. Then remove rear drums and inspect the rear brakes for problems with the brake shoes, springs, adjusters and wheel cylinders. Once a full inspection of the entire system is done, if no problems are found, then I would check the brakes for air in the system by bleeding them out. If problem continues, then check the brake master cylinder and booster along with the brake pedal linkage. If you need help pinpointing the problem, a qualified professional from YourMechanic can come to your location to diagnose the brake system and proceed with the correct fix.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Noise coming from transfer case. Not coming out of 4 wheel drive quadra drive II.

Hello. We will be happy to assist you. The issue your vehicle is having will be best pinpointed by technician. I suggest that you have a technician perform an inspection of your four wheel drive system to help find the...

I changed my TPS because of bad idle, now it stalls when I come to a stop after exceeding 50mph. What's the problem?

Hello, It sounds like you may have a faulty MAP sensor that may be creating an adverse signal to the change in engine load. The Manifold Absolute Pressure (MAP) sensor senses engine load and generates a signal that is proportional...

Every time I droves 40 or 50 and apply to the brakes,my front end shakes what can this be

The most common cause for a pulsation when the brakes are applied is warped rotors. The brake rotors will wear over time and the brake rotors are a perishable item. The rotors can warp due to excessive wear, using the...

How often do i need to do alignment?

How often you should have your vehicle aligned will vary in situation and opinion. Generally, it is a good idea to have the service done once a year or more often if you frequently drive on rough roads. Any time...

Axle Bent and Cost

Sent to CS and answer made live.

Battery group size

Hi, thanks for writing in. The main thing to keep in mind when it comes to battery group sizes is its physical size. The cold cranking amps (CCA) is what is important when it comes to the battery's ability to...

Every morning or when I use my truck i put it on drive I press on the gas and the engine will rev up but the truck goes very slow

Hello. I have a couple of ideas. You mentioned it happens in the morning and this indicates the truck is cold. When the seals in a transmission get old and hard, they allow ATF to leak internally and the transmission...

How do I use the front seat armrest?

The front seat armrest is very easy to use. Simply push it down to a horizontal position when you want to use it as an armrest, and pull it back up to a vertical position when you want the extra...

Is My Rear Wiper Legally Required to Operate?

Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards (FMVSS) specify that manufacturers must include rear wipers on all new motor vehicles sold in the United States. However, current FMVSS standards do not require that a passenger motor vehicle be equipped with a rear...

Related articles

Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Parking Brake Drum
If your car's parking brakes don't hold or just work poorly overall, you may need to replace the parking brake drum.
Can a Leak in the Brake System Cause Total Brake Failure?
Although Although there are several issues that can lead to total brake failure, the most common one is some form of brake fluid leak. When a brake leak is present, it affects the fluid pressure in your system. Since it...
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Emergency / Parking Brake Shoe
If your parking brake does not properly hold the vehicle or does not function at all, you may need to replace a parking brake shoe.