Q: My brake pedal's soft and the car's braking system is in good shape, so what can it be?

asked by on October 11, 2016

For the past month, I've noticed that the brake pedal in my car is much softer than usual, not at all as firm as it normally is (or was), and that I'm having to depress the pedal further to get the car to stop.

All rotors and brake pads have been replaced within the past three years, and I've taken it to three separate auto shops who cannot find anything wrong with the braking system, or at least nothing that's apparent to them.

So my question is: Where would you look/what would you try to do in this situation when three separate routine brake inspections have yielded no results?

My car has 147000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

First, I would road test the vehicle to verify there is a problem. Then I would check the parking brake is adjusted up tight. A loose adjusted parking brake means the rear brakes are out of adjustment. The parking brake should start to engage after the third or forth click when lifting handle slowly.

I would then remove all four wheels and check the brakes for problems with the brake lines, caliper slides, rotors, calipers and pads. Then remove rear drums and inspect the rear brakes for problems with the brake shoes, springs, adjusters and wheel cylinders. Once a full inspection of the entire system is done, if no problems are found, then I would check the brakes for air in the system by bleeding them out. If problem continues, then check the brake master cylinder and booster along with the brake pedal linkage. If you need help pinpointing the problem, a qualified professional from YourMechanic can come to your location to diagnose the brake system and proceed with the correct fix.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

My 440 Dodge Motor Home won't start.
The 440 has a flex plate with a ring gear. The starter needs to be removed and then see if the engine can be moved by hand. It may be a possibility that the starter and ring gear on the...
Sunroof not closing.
There is a way to manually close the sunroof in your vehicle. There should be cover next to the sunroof button, that when removed, has a button for manually closing the sunroof. The details of how to do this can...
Oil pressure drops to 0 "stabilitrak" issue across message center traction control shuts off but oil sending unit was just replaced
The first thing to do is to have the Check Engine Light scanned (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/check-engine-light-is-on-inspection) to see what code is stored. Once this is done, then the code should be diagnosed to see if it has anything to do with the...
Idles between 500rpm and 1300 rpm. Main concern is low rpm. Belt or pulley chirping mainly at low rpm Drives perfect but Idles bad
Chances are these two symptoms are related. If the drive belt is not performing as designed the engine will run poorly, or not run at all. There are several components that could be the problem, and further inspection is needed....
Check Engine Light keeps appearing, trouble code changed
Hi there, thanks for writing in. Having a professional mechanic complete a diagnostic inspection to determine why a mechanical part failure continues to happen is always the best course of action; especially if you're frequently replacing spark plugs on a...
car only cranks will not start. 2001 Mitsubishi Galant
Hi there - yes, the fuel pump can fail (https://www.yourmechanic.com/question/is-my-fuel-pump-working) that quickly. It's also possible that the fuse or fuel pump relay have failed, yielding the same result. You can confirm that this is a fuel supply issue by spritzing...
no start
When the engine cranks but does not start, this is usually related to a fuel or ignition issue. Since this engine has a distributor, I would recommend checking the distributor, distributor cap, and rotor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/distributor-replacement) for any damages. Then I...
How to take air out of cooling system Lexus ls400 1997?
Hi there. First check the cooling system for the right amount of coolant and top it off if its low. Then run the cooling system until the engine is hot at operating temperature. Shut off the engine and let it...
I removed my check engine light and now the car won’t go why did this happen
Hi Francesco. Thanks for contacting us today. As you probably know, when a check engine light illuminates, it's due to an OBD-II trouble code being created and is stored in the ECU. If the code is cleared and the issue...

Related articles

What Is Engine Braking?
Drivers can use engine braking to slow the speed of their engine and vehicle. Engine decompression helps your brakes last longer and car stop sooner.
How Long Does a Brake Booster Vacuum Sensor Last?
In In order for a car to have the brake power that it needs, there will have to be a sufficient amount of vacuum power. The engine of a car produces a good bit of vacuum power, but it will...
What are the Types of Brake Fluid?
Dot 3, Dot 4, and Dot 5.1 brake fluids are most common in modern vehicles. They differ in wet and dry boiling points.