Q: How can I tell if the problem I have is with the master or slave clutch cylinder? 2008 VW Eos

asked by on March 22, 2017

How can I tell if the issue is with a clutch or a slave master cylinder as symptoms are relatively the same. My clutch will not pop back up. I cannot change the gears while the engine is on. I can change the gears when the engine is off. I do not know which service to select.

My car has 98200 miles.
My car has a manual transmission.

Clutch Master Cylinder Replacement $153.16 - $485.68 Get a Quote
Clutch is not working Inspection $79.99 - $99.99 Get a Quote

Hello, thank you for writing in. Your question cannot be technically answered at this point in time. With your symptoms, it could be either the slave or the master cylinder. The clutch master cylinder is more commonly a problem, but the symptoms are identical for the most part. As far as what issue to put down for a service request, do not worry, either choice will dispatch a technician that can handle both problems regardless. Due to the fact clutch master cylinders have a higher failure rate, go ahead and select it. You can request a service for the issue here. Good luck!

Hi there - great question! Often - but not always - diagnosis of whether the clutch master cylinder fails (least often) first, or whether it’s the slave cylinder that fails first (most often) - revolves around where you find leaking clutch fluid. If it is found under the clutch area of the engine/transmission, it’s the slave cylinder that has worn and failed. Clutch master cylinder failures tend to leak clutch fluid onto the carper above the driver foot pedal area. There will be a bit of an acrid odor in the vehicle if this occurs. It’s generally a good idea to replace both whenever either of them fail - they wear out at similar rates, and bleeding the hydraulics involves both anyway. I recommend a clutch hydraulics inspection performed by a mobile, professional mechanic, such as one from YourMechanic, who will come to your location, diagnose this problem, and give you an accurate assessment of damage and cost estimate for repairs.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Misfiring Cylinder after replacing the plugs three months ago. Is it a chance that the whole batch of plugs may have been defective?

Hi there. The best thing to do is switch the coil over from cylinder 3 to cylinder 1 and see if the misfire continues with cylinder 3 or if it changes to cylinder 1. If the misfire stays with cylinder...

Faulty brake lights in a Hyundai Getz

Hey there, thanks for writing in. If you have the center light working, then the brake switch is okay and you most likely have two bad bulbs in the lights. If you need help having this repaired, a certified pro...

Does my 2007 Audi A4 Cabriolet have or support CANBUS for steering wheel control of an after market navigation system?

Unfortunately, YourMechanic does not diagnose problems with, repair, or install aftermarket sound systems. I would recommend reaching out to the products manufacturer to determine if it is compatible with your vehicle.

My ESC light comes on and I have to wait 45 minutes before I can start the car

Electronic Stabilization Control detects critical situations at an early stage, and takes action to stop skidding and help bring your car safely back under control. Check the wheel sensors for proper operation. Make sure that the sensors are plugged in...

My 2009 Toyota avanza A/T hits strongly when I kickdown the accelerator at 50km/h and the engine light comes on with a code p1706 for engine torque malfunction.

Hi there. This code is coming up for the transmission having an issue with the kickdown. There could be two things that would be wrong. Either the kickdown solenoid has failed in the transmission or the torque converter clutch solenoid...

My 2008 Subaru Forester will not move forward in any gear

Hello. If you have an automatic transmission and the vehicle will not move forward at all then most of the time this is the result of a serious internal transmission failure. It can also be caused by an issue with...

Can a timing chain be reset 2008 Chevrolet HHR

Hi there - I think your question has to do with the engine "jumping time" - that is the timing chain has jumped a cog or three on one of the sprockets, and engine management realizes one or both camshafts...

Just changed oil and oil light show on and off while driving.

Hi there: Usually when the oil light comes on after an oil change, it's an indication of low oil pressure or not enough oil inside the engine. It's possible that the oil filter was not properly installed; that the oil...

p0101 and p0172 codes

Hi there: The P0172 error code indicates that there is too much gasoline being detected in the exhaust gases exiting the combustion chamber. The ECU uses a number of instruments, such as the mass air flow sensor (MAF), oxygen sensors,...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Volkswagen Touareg TDI
The The 2012 Volkswagen Touareg TDI brings diesel to the family in a big way. This crossover SUV delivers seamless performance in a vehicle that obviously designed for the open road rather than any trails or other types of off-road...
How to Replace a Clutch Master Cylinder
The clutch master cylinder supplies fluid and pressure for the clutch system to operate. Common signs of failure include leaks or loss of pressure.
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Volkswagen Passat
Redesigned Redesigned for American buyers, the 2012 Volkswagen Passat is roomier, has more standard features, and costs less than previous models. All that, and you still get everything you look for in a German-built sedan, including the on-road dynamics, power,...