Q: Gear won't shift of out of park when I start the car

asked by on May 20, 2016

I can push the button on the shift, but the gear won't shift out of Park, even if I press hard on pedal and there are no warning lights. It happens when the RPMs start up around 2000, which my friend told me is too high when in Park. When I put my foot on the brake, the rpm will slowly come down some, but take several minutes. Then when they come down - then I can shift into gear. Since it only occasionally happens, I can't get it to occur for the dealership. What is the problem?!!

Engine idle speed is high Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

The idle speed is way too high at 2000 RPM. The first thing to correct is the shifting issue, followed by the engine speed. The throttle could be gummed up and the throttle plate could be sticking open, causing the the engine to idle high. Another thing to look at is the idle air control valve. It could be gummed up and sluggish. If it is sticking open, then the idle speed would be affected. You may want to enlist the help of a mechanic, such as one from YourMechanic, who will have the tools and expertise to diagnose and inspect why your engine idle speed is high.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

It is almost impossible to fill the tank now that the pump stops all the time
Gas station fill nozzles are designed to shut off when enough back pressure is detected, usually an indication the tank is full. However if your tank is not venting properly, it can have the same effect. Your description would indicate...
Car shimmies when braking
Hello, there is a good chance that you have warped rotors. Warped rotors can occur due to overheating or the rotors being too thin, but most often, it's a combination of both. Warped rotors should be repaired sooner than later,...
Car starts, then shakes and idles rough
The fuel injection fuel regulator is leaking fuel into the intake when you are running and causing excessive fuel to get into the engine and this is the reason you smell gas fumes from the tail pipe. The fuel regulator...
replaced the engine temp sensor and now the cooling fans wont turn on
Hello there, a few common faults will cause your cooling fans to not work after the temperature sensor was replaced on your 2003 Subaru Impreza. If the problems started right after the repair was made the replacement coolant temperature sensor...
I've got a P0507 code, what can I do?
Hi there. It sounds like the idle air control valve (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/idle-control-valve-replacement) is stuck at the high idle position. The idle air control valve is located on the throttle body assembly and allows air to bypass the throttle plate to control...
Gas won't go in car , Auto Nozzle Trips , Manually Fuel goes slowly by pressing half
The fuel inlet rollover valve and inner hose may have come loose from inside the fuel fill tube and will need to be reconnected and clamped or the inlet tube assembly replaced with a new one.
A/C pressure is high on both sides after compressor, condenser, accumulator, orifice change
Hi there. In general, high pressure on both high and low pressure AC sides is typically caused by an obstruction in the evaporator. In some cases, this can be a simple debris that can be cleaned if removed, while in...
New battery. Car won't start until minutes later when attempted again.
A voltage test will not reveal whether the battery is defective or not. A different test, referred to as a "load test" (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/battery-is-dead-inspection), is required. During these no start incidents, check to see if the engine immobilizer system (security system)...
2016 chrysler 200 service air bag light is on
Hi There, This is a known issue with this vehicle related to the malfunction of the airbag system. I would suggest taking the vehicle to your nearest Chrysler dealer to have the vehicle inspected and to determine if this is...

Related articles

How Long Does a Slave Cylinder Last?
Your Your slave cylinder is within a sealed system, so it will generally last a very long time, and may never have to be replaced. The key word here is, of course “may.” If you’re in the habit of buying...
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Shift Interlock Solenoid
The shift interlock solenoid needs to be replaced if the vehicle cannot shift out of park and the battery is not dead.
Is a Transmission Flush Necessary for My Vehicle?
A transmission flush is necessary for an automatic transmission’s longevity. It also improves fuel economy and helps validate warranties.