Q: Heater not working reliably, is it caused by a bad thermostat?

asked by on October 17, 2016

During winter last year, upstate NY... like 10 degrees outside, drive to work...NO HEAT... 20 minute ride and i warmed car up for 10 minutes before i left for work. no heat... other cold days, will be driving and heat on and NO HEAT, then in an instance HEAT... i figure thermostat bad...opening inconsistently. sound like the issue? two days ago, had 37 degrees here in NY state...drove to work...NO HEAT...just blowing cold air. Driving home later, got heat.
thanks tom

My car has 88000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Thermostat Replacement $141.88 - $613.47 Get a Quote
Heater is not working Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote

From what you’ve described, it sounds like you have a stuck open thermostat. I’d recommend replacing the thermostat to see if this is the cause of the slow heat up of the vehicle since it’s a relatively quick repair. In an area like that it sounds like you’ll will need the heat in the winter very badly and as soon as possible. I would also recommend getting a coolant flush as it may help clear any possible blockage in the heater core. To avoid any unnecessary repairs, consider YourMechanic, as one of our mobile technicians can come to your home or office to diagnose your heating issue and make the necessary repairs.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

Hose leaking antifreeze

Hello. The most common coolant leak that suddenly occurs on this engine is a water pump malfunction. It will start leaking coolant and it will appear to come from near the rear of the engine. It is also possible that...

My van is a mazda mpv 2003. Our van was overheating. So we pulled over and all our water from the radiator leaked out.

You need to check the right rear under vehicle to see if your rear a/c heater hose is leaking or broke the control valve. If you did not break a hose you can bypass heater core by connecting the two...

Coolant boils, not sure if overheating.

Hello. It does sound like a thermostat issue. If the thermostat is not opening as it should then this will occur. It also sounds like the radiator cap may not be holding pressure. I would typically test the thermostat and...

How do I update my cars software? 2011 BMW 335d

Hi - you don't mention what software component of your vehicle needs updating (engine management, infortainment or navigation system, iDrive, etc.). In general, software updates need to be done by your BMW dealer or authorized service center with software update...

My car is off, stuck in drive but the shift handle in park.

Hi Ana. Thanks for submitting your question today. It's quite possible that the gear shift lever may have broken, if the indicator is telling you the car is in "DRIVE" gear but it is pushed forward. As a safety device,...

Shaking 2011 Toyota RAV4

Hi there - occasional shaking as you describe can be a number of things - a bad CV joint/axle (tend to shake while accelerating of turning), tire or wheel problems (bent, balance issue, tire separating). Worn suspension parts can exaggerate...

Heat and air controls broken

Hi. This can be caused by two things. There are actuators or motors under the dash that operate doors in the vent system. These door direct air to the different vent locations. The actuators can be ran by vacuums or...

Issues while shifting into park - 2011 Land Rover LR4

Hello. It sounds like the parking pawl inside the transmission might be failing. When an automatic transmission is put into park, it is mechanically shifted into neutral and the pawl will engage a gear connected to the output shaft of...

What is the solution Ac off due to High engine Temp 2014 Chevrolet Cruze

Hello - first task is to check for problem codes. Most auto parts stores will do this for you for free on a time-available basis. Your symptoms suggest a failed thermostat - not closing and allow the engine to come...

Related articles

How a Car's Heating System Works
The The sun sets, and the air has a chill. You pause to flip your jacket collar up, and you walk briskly to your car door and slide into the driver's seat. Once you start your car, it’s only moments...
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Vacuum Pump
Common signs include poor fuel efficiency, difficulty pressing the brake pedal, oil leaking under the engine, and the AC not working.
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2011 Ford Ranger
The The 2011 Ford Ranger offers affordable pricing with excellent styling. It is a compact pickup that is both inexpensive to operate and own. The vehicle is capable of going off-road while still being able to tow 1,600 to 3,100...