Q: Engine is running rough and P0401, P0171 and P0174 codes.

asked by on May 10, 2016

Trying to diagnose codes listed above. Tested EGR for plugged or restricted lines. Checked OK. Will stall engine when idling and you cover EGR Control Solenoid vent with your finger. Pulled EGR valve and lines to visually check. All OK. All electrical checks of EGR Solenoid and DPFE are OK. Found vacuum to EGR valve keeping EGR valve open all the time engine is running. When tested with a vacuum guage you have 5 inches of mercury at idle which increases to 18 to 20 when you depress accelerator and drops back to 5 inches when you release accelerator. This happens even when truck is in PARK and engine is running. I think this is causing engine to act like it has a large vacuum leak which I think would cause the P0171 and P0174. I don't know what is causing the EGR Solenoid to allow the vacuum to pass through and open EGR Valve. Any advice? Sincerely, Ron Zara
My car has an automatic transmission.

Check Engine Light is on Inspection $79.99 - $89.99 Get a Quote

The first thing to check is to see if the EGR solenoid will release the vacuum when the electrical connector is disconnected. If it still doesn’t release the vacuum then the solenoid should be replaced. The codes need to be cleared and the vehicle should be driven to see if any of the codes come back.

The EGR solenoid has a small foam filter on the vent side and it is there to keep dirt out of the valve. If dirt gets into it, the solenoid will be held open and allow vacuum to pass through it. If you find that the solenoid is not leaking vacuum when the connector is disconnected then you may have a problem with the DPFE telling the ECM to open the valve. From what it seems like, I think you will find the solenoid is going to be the problem. I’d recommend having a certified mechanic check your vehicle out, they will be able to properly diagnose your Check Engine Light codes and make the necessary repair.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

No start

If Diagnostic Trouble Codes were downloaded, those codes would really would be key to advising you. If there is no spark, obviously all ignition system components are possible suspects but if the coil(s) and spark plugs are new, the crankshaft...

My car is skipping - do I need new spark plug wires?

Old or faulty spark plug wires can definitely be a cause for the engine to misfire, however there are numerous other reasons that may also cause this to happen. Generally, misfires are caused by either a spark or fuel issue...

What Are the Top Transmission Problems That Should Never Be Ignored?

Ignoring problems with cars is like ignoring problems with teeth. Waiting longer usually just results in more pain and expense. Seeing transmission fluid on the ground under your vehicle should get your attention right away. Transmission fluid is usually reddish-brown....

After multiple replacements, gas mileage is worse - 1997 Ford Aspire

The fuel economy will change depending on the whether the transmission is manual or automatic. According to fueleconomy.gov the manual transmission Ford Aspire is getting a combined 33mpg while the automatic get 26mpg. Ford's initial adverts were 34 mpg city...

EVAP leak needs repairing.

Hi there, the code is a common one. The test procedure involves physically inspecting the canister for fuel. The canister should only house fuel vapors not fuel. If no fuel is present then the purge valve needs to be tested...

Reduced Engine Power message

The "Reduced Engine Power" message is the computer going into failure mode. This mode is to protect you from a possible problem of the throttle getting too high. The mode happens when one of the engine sensors is having a...

Motor mount/waterpump bolt froze

When dealing with a broken off bolt there are a few different ways to fix this. One of which involves drilling out the broken off bolt and extracting it using a reverse drill bit. Another way is to drill out...

Transmission shudders when accelerating from a stop

This may be related to a faulty transmission control solenoid or low transmission fluid. As you may know, automatic transmissions use pressurized hydraulic fluid to change gears. When a gear change is required, the car's computer activates a transmission solenoid,...

Car not accelerating

This issue could be caused by something as simple as the emergency brake being left on, but that is usually the first thing that would be checked. If the emergency brake is off then there could be an issue with...

Related articles

The 10 Most Important Things in Your Car Owner’s Manual
Your owner's manual tells you important information about your car, like how to set up your car, how to check car fluids, and correct tire pressure.
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Oxygen Sensor
Common signs of a faulty car oxygen sensor include the Check Engine Light coming on, bad gas mileage, and a rough idle.
P0878 OBD-II Trouble Code: Transmission Fluid Pressure Sensor/Switch D Circuit High
P0878 means the PCM has detected an abnormal pressure within the transmission fluid sensor/switch often due too low fluid levels or malfunction.