Q: Catalytic converter is working, but will not kick in to pass smog.

asked by on November 07, 2016

Replaced sensors in 2000 Grand Prix, because it would not pass smog. Now all the sensors work, but the Cat will not kick in, to pass smog. The mechanics all say there is nothing wrong with the Cat. They said to drive it, and it would finally kick in. Well after 1000 miles, it has not kicked in. Three different repair stations can not figure out why it won't kick in. All the sensors are fine, and so is the Cat. They said it does not need to be replaced. Can you help? Thank you.

My car has 173000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Exhaust System Inspection $79.99 - $99.99 Get a Quote
Catalytic Converter Replacement $291.63 - $3224.07 Get a Quote

The O2 sensors monitors catalytic converter efficiency, it does not control the catalytic converter. Catalytic converters either work well enough or they don’t. If it won’t kick in, it needs a new one. Cat’s work independent of all other systems. They simply catalyze the remaining HC’s (hydrocarbons) in the exhaust stream. If it isn’t doing this, it is bad. If the cat is original on your car with 173,000 miles, it is definitely due for one. This would be a normal maintenance cycle.

I have to point out, if the cat is not working, how can it be good? If it is good, your car would pass emissions. There are not any electrical components to turn it on. It is turned on when it reaches operating temperature as supplied by the heat that is created by the motor and transferred through the exhaust. There is only one possible system that can affect the cat operation. That would be the air injection system that is used to warm the cat up as quickly as possible when it is cold. If this system is not operating, then the cat will warm to slowly and will not operate soon enough in a drive cycle. Other the air system, a cat either works or it does not.

I recommend contacting customer service to see if there is a technician in your area with the tools and experience to diagnose this issue and service your catalytic converter as necessary. I find it disconcerting that three shops could not figure this out.

Good luck!

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Worse case scenario if the electronic throttle has to be replaced about how much would it cost

The best course of action would be to have a diagnosis first since the throttle control may be limited if you are having a system or sensor failure in the drivetrain like a transfer case or transmission issue. You may...

how's the maintenance /cost of repair compared to bmw or mercedes cars of the same issues? more costky or less?

Hi there. In general, UK & European vehicles (BMW, Mercedes, Volvo and others) have higher than average service, maintenance and repair costs due to the fact that most mechanics that can complete them are specialists. The cost of repair per...

Heard loud noise, engine light turned on, the a/c stopped working and the car was very hard to drive. I saw a broken hose. Help!

Overheating can be caused by a number of issues. The hose blown off could be the cause as well as an effect. The engine could have begun to overheat before the hose blew off due to things like a stuck...

Starter will not stay engaged long enough to start car ?

Hi There, It sounds like you may have a faulty starter solenoid or potentially a bad starter motor. A faulty starter solenoid will generally produce a clicking sound when turning the key. The starter solenoid is located on the starter...

Replacing starter,

If you took the starter main housing bolts out and removed the main housing then you may have damaged brushes inside the starter. I recommend removing the starter and check the brushes for damaged and replace the starter f they...

what could cause my oil to not return to the oil pan?

If your vehicle has not had regular oil changes, sludge will form internally and may block oil return passages. After you warm it up, remove the valve cover cap and look inside to see if oil is building up. It...

The ignition is locked up and the car cannot be started

Most modern vehicles now have small moving parts inside the ignition switch of the vehicle. If any of these small moving parts become misaligned, this could cause the ignition switch to lock up. When this issue occurs, the most common...

Gearshift sticking

Cables are covered by a hard plastic sleeve. The cable is actually exposed only at the ends. the largest portion of exposed cable is at the shifter. This means it is susceptible to debris that falls through the console. Things...

Related articles

How to Replace an Exhaust Gas Recirculation (EGR) Tube
The EGR valve is connected to an EGR pipe, which helps distribute molecules through your vehicle’s EGR system. A bad pipe leads to performance issues.
What Causes an Exhaust Manifold to Crack or Leak?
Your car has two manifolds – an intake manifold and an exhaust manifold. Both serve essential purposes, but the one most likely to...
What Metal Is the Exhaust System Made From?
Exhaust Exhaust systems must be made from metal to provide the required durability and resistance to heating, cooling and exposure to the elements. However, there are many different types of metals (and grades of individual metals). There are also differences...