Q: Car will not shift and stalls - 2016 Subaru WRX

asked by on September 16, 2016

After purchasing my car this year, I only had nearly 600 miles on it when I started having problems with the clutch and transmission. I was leaving the highway and shifted out of 6th gear. Then I was about to shift into 3rd while driving through an intersection and it would not shift into any gear; it was stuck in neutral and I had the clutch pedal completely depressed. I then pulled over to the side of the street, turned off the car and then restarted it before the transmission would go into gear.

Next, the problem occurred again at 3500 miles. I was driving on the highway having to shift from 5th into 6th. Pressing the clutch I shifted out of 5th and it would not shift into 6th or into any gear at all. I got on the shoulder of the highway and it just would not shift into any gear. Turned off the car and began to restart the car, with transmission in neutral. When I released the clutch, the car stalled. Then, I put it into 1st and pressed the clutch and the car started. But when it started, it lunged/jerked forward. I got back on the highway and immediately went to the dealership. They couldn’t do anything until replicating the problem and the problem wouldn’t happen for them! Since this last time, I started smelling a strong burning smell when at low speeds and shifting from 1st to 2nd and also when cruising highway speeds in 6th gear.

Around 1,000 miles later it happened again, but this time (at 35 mph) in addition to not being able to shift into any gear, the clutch pedal would not come up all the way. Before the clutch would come up all the way, I had to press it several times and then it went into gear. During this time I could smell the burning smell. I went back to the dealership and once again, the problem would not happen for them so they won’t do a thing. Please tell me what is causing this and what is your advice how it can be fixed. Thank you.

Hey there. Considering the burning smell, there may be a problem in the hydraulic circuit of the clutch system. A failing clutch master or slave cylinder can cause the problems you are having. To have this diagnosed more thoroughly, a certified technician from YourMechanic can come to your car’s location to inspect the shifting and stalling problem to have this addressed correctly.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Key won't turn
Hi there. If the key isn't able to turn, try turning the wheel back and forth a few times while turning the key to unlock everything. Modern cars tend to have a locking system that will lock the steering wheel...
My car jerks when decelerating from what seems to be 4th gear to 3rd.
You need to have the codes scanned by a professional with a scan tool for the transmission computer. The codes may give you an indication if the sensor is not performing correctly. If it is not a sensor malfunctioning (like...
Steel hose leaking antifreeze - 1992 Plymouth Acclaim V6
Hi there, thanks for your question. If the pipe is leaking coolant, it must be some type of cooler line or coolant bypass hose. There are several terms for these and it can be confusing finding the right parts. Sometimes...
Car will not start intermittently while in PARK but always starts on NEUTRAL.
Hi there, thank you for writing in and providing a detailed description. I'd be happy to give my insight on what to do next. I would make the same conclusion about the neutral safety switch (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-neutral-safety-switch). I think Pep Boys...
Okay so I was in a race but when we started the race I pressed the tow/haul button.
Hello. I am not too sure about the question you are asking. From what you've described, it sounds like you used the tow/haul button when you raced your truck and ever since the engine is making noise. If this is...
Brake pedal feels hard
It sounds as though you may have a brake hose that has collapsed inside. There are three flexible hydraulic hoses on your car that allow the brake lines to move with the wheels. There are two on the front and...
I have a loss of power and I can't really press on the gas too hard or the engine will start shaking/stalling
The engine may have a vacuum leak in the throttle intake tube between the mass air flow sensor and the throttle body. Or the mass air flow sensor may not be working correctly or is contaminated. Have the computer scanned...
I have a 1997 nissan maxima that has a misfire code of p0300 and p0302.
It's common to find the source of a misfire in the ignition system. Checking the coils with an Ohmmeter doesn't really tell you much though. When I diagnose a misfire, sometimes I find it helpful to swap the coils and...
Car shuts off in neutral and in park
Hello. We will be happy to assist you. There are few things that I recommend you have a technician check on your vehicle. Being that coolant sprayed everywhere they would want to check the electrical connectors and wiring for any...

Related articles

How to Troubleshoot a Slipping Clutch
There are numerous advantages to operating a vehicle with a manual transmission; many drivers claim it gives them more control over...
The Mechanics of Cars: Simple Machines in Automobiles
Simple Simple machines are single, mechanical devices that help improve the daily life of humans by allowing them to work faster, easier, and more efficiently. Simple machines are considered to be the basic mechanisms that all complex machines...
How to Replace a Clutch Slave Cylinder
Clutch slave cylinders need to be replaced if brake fluid leaks. If gears grind or the clutch won’t, the clutch pedal may be at fault.