Q: Car dies while idling in neutral and wont turn over without jumpbox even though battery reads 12.4 volts when parked

asked by on November 29, 2017

My girlfriends car is a 99 Subaru outback legacy. The other day on way home from work kept stalling out and wanting to die. Then next day it did die. It wont turn over or crank unless i hook up jump box. Without jump box just clicks. Even tho the battery reads 12.4 volts on battery meter. Once key is turned to start, meter displays nothing and car just clicks. Once key is turned back the battery shows 12.4 volts again. Car will sometimes stay running just fine in park after being jumped, but when idling in neutral at a light it dies. There is a annoying whining noise coming from under the coil pack and a weird electrical burning type smell that's coming through vents. I removed the cables from the battery and hooked em directly to jump box and it starts. But don't know why even with the battery showing over 12 volts won't start. And I'm trying to figure out cause of the car dying while idling in neutral and sometimes in park and feeling like it wants to die other times.

My car has 130000 miles.
My car has a manual transmission.

Even though the battery shows 12 volts does not mean it can have enough power to turn the motor on and will need to be load tested to see if it can. Once the battery is replaced and the cables are cleaned you will need to have the charging system checked to see if alternator needs replaced also. This may be the noise and smell you are getting.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

What does the parking brake warning mean?
If your parking brake is on, you’ll see the Parking Brake light on the dash. However, you will also see a warning shown in the vehicle information display that tells you the parking brake is set. This warning is meant...
Headlights and taillights don't work
Hello. If both of these stopped working at the same time it is usually the switch. This is the most common failure on this car. I would usually check the wiring to the switch for voltage first before replacing the...
all lights on the left side of my car wont work
The rear lights share the same power and the same ground so these may be bulb issues. The front lights, however, have the same power but different grounds. The grounds for the left side is in the left front corner...
code is p0340 i change camshaft position sensor but still shows same code .any help or advice
Hi there: The problem with changing out the camshaft position sensor is that sometimes the issue is actually due to the sensor wiring harness; which might be the reason this OBD-II error code was triggered initially. The P-0340 trouble code...
Clicking sound appears during decelerating. What could it be?
Hi there. What you could be hearing is the chain in the transfer case. If the chain has too much play, then the chain will rub on the transfer case housing when not under a load. Try going up a...
I failed a smog check with the codes PO171 & PO174, saying the system is too lean on the bank 1 & 2. Can you tell me what the problem is?
Hi there. When the two codes P0171 (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/p0171-obd-ii-trouble-code-system-too-lean-bank-1-by-andrew-quinn) and P0174 (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/p0174-obd-ii-trouble-code-system-too-lean-bank-2-by-blake-griffin) come up for a lean system on both banks of your engine, then either all of the fuel injectors are not working properly or your fuel pressure has dropped....
Car won't start after getting gas
The most common cause for this hard or no start after getting fuel is the purge valve is leaking fumes to the engine while fueling the vehicle. You should first have any computer codes checked by scanning the computer and...
If I have a bad throttle position sensor will my car hesitate to start
Hello There, I believe you are correct in that you may have a faulty throttle position sensor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/throttle-position-sensor-replacement). There are trouble codes that are typically associated with the TPS. One code will set if the TPS voltage is too high...
Corrosion on starter terminals
Corrosion on the terminals will definitely impact the flow of current to the starter. The other potential issue may be a faulty connection to the starter relay (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/starter-relay-replacement). If the starter relay is faulty or not receiving the proper current,...

Related articles

Understanding Electric Vehicles
For For people who grew up in a world where electric vehicles (EVs) existed only in cartoons and science fiction movies, seeing one pull up alongside you at a red light is still an unusual sight. Still, every day there...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You Just Got Your License
If If you are a new driver, congratulations on getting your license. Now, you need to think about what type of vehicle to buy. Ideally, you’ll choose a used car that isn’t overly expensive, and is reliable and safe while...
How to Buy a Good Quality Car Charger
It’s It’s probably happened to you before, you’re out running errands only to realize your cell phone battery has died. So now what? This is why it’s a great idea to have a portable car charger in your car at...