Q: Broke down on the highway and had towed to a Buick dealer. They diagnosed and replaced the catalytic converter.

asked by on August 06, 2016

I drove it 25 miles and the check engine light came on. Brought it back and they said the new converter is bad. I suggested from the beginning that the muffler could be plugged. What are the odds of a new converter last 25 miles. Car drove ok.

My car has 48000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

It is possible that the new catalytic converter is bad. Sometimes, when the converter comes apart inside, it can get into the muffler and cause it to be clogged.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Bad wheel bearing at front of car.
A grinding noise would indicate that the brake may be worn out. Have a technician look at it to determine if the brakes are worn out (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/brake-safety-inspection-inspection) or the wheel bearing is bad. A bad wheel bearing would be a...
Car won't start, even though lights and radio working.
While the lights and radio may be working in your Chrysler Sebring, if you are unable to start the car and hear the starter crank the engine over, then you may have either a weak battery, a bad starter or...
Car making spinning, rattling noise
The first problem I think of is spark knocking or pinging. This is when the combustion of the air/fuel mixture in the cylinder does not start off correctly in response to ignition by the spark plug, but one or more...
Electronics don't work after jumpstart
Jumping a vehicle is a great way to receive instant power. On the other hand this can cause electrical issues if not done correctly. Multiple fuses can blow leaving you with a loss of power to many components in your...
Just got code P0430. How long till catalytic converter fails completely?
Hi, thanks for writing in. This P0430 code (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/p0430-obd-ii-trouble-code-catalyst-system-efficiency-below-threshold-bank-2-by-spencer-clayton) is for the bank B or driver side converter or the O2 sensor after the converter. The code will need to be diagnosed to isolate the problem to the sensor or...
Is it my thermostat in my car that is not working?
You are correct, you probably do have an issue with the thermostat. When your thermostat is stuck in the closed position it doesn't allow coolant to run through the engine which is why you have the cooling effect. It will...
My car runs and shifts gears but will not move what can be problem 1995 Pontiac Grand Am
Hello - check for problem codes, whether the Check Engine light is on or not. Most auto parts stores will do this for free on a "time-available" basis. It is possible a component of the shift linkage (https://www.yourmechanic.com/question/gearshift-not-working) in the...
My 1999 ford wind star came with a locked glovebox with no key. How do I get into the glovebox without damaging it?
Hello, thank you for writing in. If preventing damage, you have two different options. One is to order a new key from the dealership. The other is to have a professional locksmith pick the lock. These locks (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/door-does-not-lock-or-open-inspection) are simple...
2004 Lincoln ls v6 my car runs bad when cold until it hits normal temp. The breaks are stiff during the warm up process
To identify the cause of poor operation like that you are describing, the cylinder firing patterns have to be looked at on a scope. That diagnostic reveals whether the issue is fuel or ignition related and also which cylinders are...

Related articles

P0471 OBD-II Trouble Code: Exhaust Pressure Sensor Range/Performance
P0471 means the powertrain control module has detected an voltage that is out of the normal range due to the exhaust back pressure system.
P0246 OBD-II Trouble Code: Turbocharger Wastegate Solenoid High
P0246 code means the solenoid circuit reading does not fall within the recommended specifications due to a damaged solenoid, or faulty wiring.
P2768 OBD-II Problem Code: Input/Turbine Speed Sensor B Circuit Intermediate
P2768 means a varying, erratic, or irrational signal is sent from the turbine speed sensor due to a faulty sensor, solenoid, or shorted circuits.