Q: After heating core replacement, oil gone and engine ruined

asked by on June 02, 2016

The heating core had to be replaced in our car. An oil change had been done 2,000 miles before the heating core replacement; plus, all the fluids checked out correctly. Within one week, after the heating core replacement, all of the oil had burned up and now the engine is ruined!! There were no leaks and no smoke from the engine. There were no warnings at all! What went wrong with the new heating core and what should I do?

Hello. The heater core would not have anything to do with the oil. If anything they may not have properly installed one of the heater hoses which may have causes the coolant to leak which would have caused the engine to overheat. If the engine got hot enough then the oil would sludge up and appear as if there is no oil. This will be vey hard to diagnose and to prove that the shop is the cause of this without determining if the coolant leaked out.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

oil change frequency
The oil change interval in the oil change monitor was set to 7500 mile intervals by the factory. You can just reset it, but it will continue to go off every 7500 miles. This is just an alert, not an...
cut off while driving and running rough
Hello there, many different faults will cause your 1999 Dodge Grand Caravan to run poorly and shut off. The most common would be the spark plugs, plug wires, coil, fuel pump, fuel filter, alternator, vacuum leak, battery, wiring harness fault...
Abs and handbrake light staying on
Hi, thanks for writing in. It is possible that the sensor, or another component, was damaged during the repair. If you would like help, consider having an expert automotive technician from YourMechanic come to your home or office to inspect...
Replacing front brake pad and reasonable dealership cost
Hi there. I understand your concern. I start suggesting brake pad replacement at 3mm. Most technicians have a brake pad thickness gauge that takes the guesswork out of determining when to suggest brake pads replacement; 1-3mm is red, 4-6mm is...
Engine whining in 1st gear & 2nd gear
Hello. It is not the engine whining but the transmission internal bearings that are whining. I would recommend having a mechanic verify the noise (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/whining-sound-when-car-is-in-gear-inspection) is in the transmission and see if the transmission needs internal repairs. Depending on the...
Coolant evaporating very quickly - 2001 Toyota Camry
Hello. If the coolant continues to go low, then there is a problem with the vehicle. It can be an external leak or the engine may have an internal failure which is causing the coolant to burn off. Since you...
The transmission went out on my 2010 GMC Terrain, at 55,000 miles, with no warning. Last year, under a recall, I had the timing fixed.
Hi there. With the limited detailed information that is provided about your situation, I can input that the transmission may have had a fluid leak or the vehicle was used for pulling a trailer that was overloaded. The transmission in...
Turn signal blowing fuse
Hello, thank you for writing in. When a fuse continues to blow, there is an extra power source coming from somewhere. Typically this means there is a short somewhere in the system. Tracing out this short can be difficult. If...
Ck engine soon light is on
If your vehicle's check engine light (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/what-does-the-check-engine-warning-light-mean-by-spencer-cates) illuminates, there is a malfunction that should be investigated and repaired. However, the seriousness of the malfunction is hard to judge unless and until a Code Scanner is used by the Mechanic to...

Related articles

How to Buy a Good Quality Cooling System Flush
Your Your radiator does the important job of helping to keep the engine cool. Overheating can cause serious, expensive damage like a blown head gasket (which typically requires complete engine replacement) or warped cylinders. The radiator circulates and cools the...
Symptoms of a Bad or Failing Coolant Temperature Switch (Sensor)
Common signs include poor fuel economy, black smoke coming from the engine, engine overheating, and the Check Engine Light turning on.
How to Pressure Test a Radiator Cap
Radiator caps are pressure tested using a cooling system pressure tester. This shows if the pressure in the cooling system is at a healthy level.