Q: What is making this noise?

asked by on October 29, 2015

My 2007 Ford F-150 (5.4L Triton, automatic, 120k miles) was making a loud clingy noise after it had warmed up. If I turned it off then back on, the noise stopped. I was told by a mechanic it was the cam phasers and it was throwing off the timing, so I paid to have them fixed. The truck ran ok for a few days and then the same noise started again. I took it back and the mechanic said oil was not getting through the engine properly and the phasers were bad. They again replace the phasers, oil lines, etc. and it still knocks at startup. If I give it a jolt of acceleration, it stops for a bit but on the next stop it happens again. All the mechanics I talk to are at a loss. What can be done to fix this?

Your description of engine knocking at idle with your 2007 Ford F-150 5.4 Triton engine is a common complaint for owners of this engine. I recommend you have a certified mechanic, like one from YourMechanic, do some preliminary checks to help isolate your problem. This complaint has to be isolated to properly diagnose it. The most common problems found is the oil pressure being at or above 25psi when the engine is cold, and lower than 25psi at idle when warm, due to oil getting thinner. The low oil pressure in a warm engine would cause timing issues with cam phasers and timing chain tensioner. The reason the issue seems to go away as you accelerate is that the oil pressure will increase as the engine RPM’s increase. Continued running with low oil pressure will cause internal damage to bearings, the crankshaft, camshafts and other internal components lubricated by oil. The cam phasers require proper oil pressure and oil viscosity. Ford recommends 5w20w for your engine. If you are using an oil that is too high of viscosity or of a wrong weight, this can cause not enough oil to reach critical parts and cause erratic cam phaser operation or internal wear. As long as the correct oil is being used then the problems described will only occur with low oil pressure. I have heard of recommendations of using straight 30 weight oil and that it quiets the noise on occasions. I do not recommend this practice, since it could cause wear damage due to tighter part tolerances or orifices that may not get enough oil to work correctly. When you get your oil pressure checked, if it is below 25psi at idle, I would recommend getting a certified mechanic to drop the oil pan, remove and inspect thrust bearings on crankshaft for excessive wear. If the pressure is ok, then replace the oil pump and screen. If bearings show excessive wear or damage, then a major overhaul or replacement of engine will be needed.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

What others are asking

2001 Ford Focus Won't start

Hi there. The fuel pump is in the fuel tank. You will have a fuel test port on the engine fuel rail. You should have fuel pressure when you cycle the key to on for a few seconds and during...

Could you show me what it looks like?

Hi there. First check the fuel filter and see if the filter is plugged up. If your vehicle has a tank filter and not a inline filter, then check the fuel pump relay and see if it's clicking on when...

01 mustang v6 running rough at idle and drive. Please help. Replaced a bunch, still can't figure out issue.

This may be a sign of a faulty MAP sensor as the vehicle responds adversely to a load put on the motor (i.e. putting it in gear, turning on AC or engaging the brakes). The Manifold Absolute Pressure (MAP) sensor...

What do the various lights mean on the instrument cluster?

Your car’s instrument cluster contains quite a few different lights, all of which provide you with information about different systems (most of which you activate yourself during the course of normal driving). Here’s a quick rundown of what you should...

Gear oil leak.

Hello. Pinion bearing seals can leak due to normal wear or as a result of excessive pinion bearing play. A growling sound can indicate a worn pinion bearing as well. If the noise changes during acceleration, the cause is most...

Rough idle on car

Hello. The most common cause of a rough idle on this engine is a vacuum leak. Most of the time this is caused by a loose or broken vacuum hose. With the engine running you can listen for any hissing...

Ticking and white smoke

Hi there. Overfilling the oil can cause issues, but in most cases it has to be an extreme overfill. Often leaks can develop along with noise and smoke. Worst case scenario, it can cause mechanical damage to the engine. The...

I need help with the glove box removal.

Hi there. To remove the glove box there are two Torx screws just inside on the top of the glove box. On bottom under the base of glove box door (external) are two 8mm bolts. Once the screws and bolts...

squeaky idler pulley

Replace the entire tensioner assembly since the tension is what caused the pulley to go bad. You should also replace the belt if any damage is noted.

Related articles

A Guide to Motor Oil Additives
Motor oil contains various additives to make it perform better. Conventional and synthetic oils both contain additives which help prevent engine wear.
How to Buy a Good Quality Oil Cooler Hose (Automatic Transmission)
If If you’re seeing black stains beneath your vehicle when it’s parked, that oil slick could be caused by a leak in your oil cooler hose. The oil cooler acts as a radiator by cooling the engine oil after it...
4 Essential Things to Know About Truck Caps and Cargo Boxes
Trucks Trucks are not known for having huge amounts of space in the cockpit, so creating a way to keep things organized in the back of your truck can be a lifesaver. How do you choose whether to go with...