Q: Water pump issue

asked by on June 14, 2016

If a very small amount of pink antifreeze is crystalized around the metal hose of the water pump leading to the engine, does this mean the water pump needs to be replaced?

My car has 40700 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Water Pump Replacement $187.27 - $1236.57 Get a Quote
Oil/Fluid Leak Inspection $94.99 - $114.99 Get a Quote

Most people wouldn’t say yes, it needs to be replaced. But the truth is, there is a bit of an argument within the industry about this. Before I go to far into that, let’s make sure we are clear on the form of leak we have here. I’m assuming there isn’t any liquid, only a crystallized stain at the water pump weep hole. If there is any wet drips or evidence of stains that indicate antifreeze has been running wet, then I would say the water pump should be replaced. Look directly below the pump to see if there is any evidence of a larger leak. A water pump seal is a unique seal that under certain circumstances will seep coolant. This is what you see in the form of crystallized antifreeze.

From my perspective, at 40,700 miles, as long as there isn’t any wet antifreeze dripping or pooling anywhere, I wouldn’t worry about it. Water pump seals will often weep when they are in the process of cooling or warming. This is more prevalent in climates that experience extremes such as snow or desert summertime temperatures. Water pump seals are spring loaded devices that are designed to work within the varying pressures that are normal for a cooling system. When the environment is extreme, it pushes these seals to their limit. I’ve seen vehicles that actually leak on warm up or cool down, but not when cold or fully warm. It’s not very often and newer vehicles have better designed pump seals, but the inherent weakness is still an engineering challenge.

I draw the line at wet weep holes or dripping. Even then, this is often a manageable condition. Short of running coolant out the weep hole at a constant rate, no matter the temperature, keep track of your coolant level. A weeping hole is not much more than a couple of drops of coolant. You shouldn’t be able to detect any loss from such a small weep.

Another detail that is important, but I wouldn’t expect to see on a 40,000 mile vehicle, is particulates flowing through the cooling system. If you see any evidence of small particles in the cooling system, this can damage the water pump seal and create leaks. If this is the case, I recommend a complete flush of the cooling system. In which case the best way to flush a cooling system is by removing the water pump and thoroughly flushing water through the block with a water hose. But I have never seen a 40,000 mile Toyota have such a problem, so this is doubtful.

If you need assistance and want a professional to take a closer look, a certified mechanic from YourMechanic can visit your home or office to inspect the fluid leak.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

What does it mean if the smart key warning light comes on?
If your car has a smart key system, then it’s equipped with a warning light and buzzer that help in certain situations when the electronic key might be missing or out of range. There are several light/buzzer combinations that might...
Car not changing gears
I'm going to assume you have a manual transmission. The transmission in your Ford is a G15M-R fully synchronized 5-speed. Your problem could be with the clutch or clutch hydraulics. If a transmission is hard to shift into gear, or...
Why does my truck cut off when the TPS is unplugged
Hello there, A few different items can cause the truck to shut off this way. The TPS may not be the cause. Most likely causes would be a vacuum leak, MAF sensor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-mass-airflow-sensor), oxygen sensor (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-oxygen-sensor), or an exhaust leak....
Vibrates at 65 mph
A few different things can cause the vehicle to vibrate at freeway speeds. The brake rotors (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-a-bad-or-failing-brake-rotor-disc), brake pads (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/symptoms-of-bad-or-failing-brake-pads), and tire balance are a great place to start. Other common causes would be the tire itself, bent rim, wheel...
My TC light is on and I don't know what that means. Got this car 2 weeks ago.
Hi, thanks for writing in. The TC light is the traction control light (https://www.yourmechanic.com/question/what-does-the-traction-control-system-tcs-off-light-mean_2_21789). This light will come on when the traction control has a malfunction or when it has been deactivated by the switch. Usually the traction control issues...
P0306 code after replacing COP, wires and spark plugs. What else could it be?
There are several possible causes for an engine misfire. There could be an injector problem, a wiring or connector problem, a PCM problem, or even a problem within the engine. Some further diagnostics will be necessary to locate the cause....
Changing my radio, and may be the whole dash (center console) 2010 Cadillac SRX
Hello - your English is very good actually. Yes, your plan makes good sense. The radio (or 'infotainment center' as they are now called) is modular, and at least within your make and model, fairly interchangeable. A radio/infotainment cluster from...
Shaking at high and low speeds.
Hi Javier. Thanks for contacting us tonight. What you're describing seems to indicate an issue with your wheel bearings. Typically if you hear a grinding or high pitched squealing noise when you turn to one side and at high and...
"This morning Engine Light, Traction Control Light, and Electronic steering light is on. " I went to Honda dealership last week an
Hi Iqbal. Thanks for sending the question today. Warning lights simply indicate that a possible fault has been detected by the sensor monitoring the system. In most cases, when the light illuminates, it's due to an electrical glitch, poor connection,...

Related articles

A Buyer’s Guide to the 2012 Toyota Sequoia
If If you need to haul a crowd and you want the power needed to haul all the toys as well, the 2012 Toyota Sequoia might be a perfect fit. While it doesn’t have the hauling capacity of some of...
A Buyer’s Guide to the 2011 Toyota Land Cruiser
This This multi-tasking full-size SUV offers all the versatility of a traditional mini-van with the amenities and comfort level of a high-end sedan. Add in the 4WD that allows you to chew up rough terrain if desired (or necessary) and...
2012 Toyota Prius vs. 2012 Chevrolet Volt: Which One Should I Buy?
While these two vehicles are both certainly cost-effective to drive, they can be difficult to compare due to the Prius’ entry in the mid-size category and the Volt living squarely in the compact car category. Both of these vehicles are...