Skip the auto shop - Our mechanics make house calls

Q: Should I trade?

asked by on

My teenager drives this car, and so did her older sister before her. We bought it used and have owned it for 9 years. My oldest wrecked it twice, never her fault, and substantial damage was done to the involved cars, but never this one. We did replace a side mirror and fix a dent.

The car has needed new struts for several years, but I have not done that as the estimate was about $1500, which may be more than the car is worth. I also don't carry collision insurance.

The car drives great and is a part of the family. However, it's about to need new brakes again, I just replaced a brake hose, and I never know what it will need next.

My biggest concern is safely, but as a single mom, cost of repairs is also an issue.

Can you confirm that it's probably time to purchase something else, and suggest something that is less expensive to buy/maintain, and comes close to the safety record of a Volvo? I would probably purchased a used vehicle from Carmax.

Thanks! Lynn

My car has 170000 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Hi Lynn, thanks for writing in. Having two kids myself, I’ve been in your shoes. My rule of thumb is that if the cost of repairs today outnumbers the low blue book value of the vehicle, you should consider buying a newer vehicle. Although I’m a fan of Volvos (in regards to safety), one problem they have is once they reach 150,000 miles, some of them start to get expensive to repair and maintain. Believe it or not, right now Volkswagens are selling incredibly cheap (mostly due to the poor PR they got with the manipulated emissions systems). Volkwagens tend to be very good in regards to safety, especially Jettas and GTIs. Otherwise, Nissans, Hondas, and Toyotas tend to be the most economic and less expensive to repair. A good resource for buying a good used car is Edmunds.com for professional reviews and ratings. We also have a few good articles you can read here on YourMechanic.com about tips for buying used cars. Also, we offer pre-purchase car inspections if you decide to buy a used car. Best of luck in your search.

Was this answer helpful?

Need advice from certified mechanic? Get help now!

Over 1000 mechanics are ready to answer your question.
The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

Get a quote

What others are asking

Q: Considering purchasing, however, I am leery of possible high maintenance costs associated with this vehicle. Dependable? High maintenance?

Going from a BMW 135i to a 2014 Porsche Cayenne will obviously cost more in maintenance through the years. From special procedures during repairs, more expensive parts and higher labor costs, you can only expect the upkeep costs to go...

Q: Is the 2004 Volvo S60 a good car

In evaluating the wisdom of buying a particular model of car (used or new), consult the database of the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, NHTSA. The NHTSA database contains year, make and model specific consumer complaints, official recalls and factory...

Q: What is a fair value

Hello. A salvaged title generally deducts 20-40% of the Kelly BlueBook value. I would look at kbb.com to determine the fair market value of your vehicle, and then deduct 20-40% dependent on how well it was repaired. Be sure to...

Related articles

How Do Power Car Windows Increase Passenger Safety?
Power windows are responsible for approximately 2,000 emergency room visits every year. When a power window closes, it exerts enough force to bruise or break bones, crush fingers, or restrict an airway. Though...
How Long Does a Distributor O Ring Last?
The distributor is part of the ignition system in your vehicle and its purpose is to route high voltage from the ignition coil to the spark plug. The spark plug then...
How to Avoid Back Pain in a Car
If you have back problems, sitting in a car for an extended period of time can be excruciating. Even without back problems, you could experience discomfort and soreness from...