Q: Rotational thumping/noise from front left wheel

asked by on June 23, 2016

OK so I have had this thumping for awhile, I took the car to the shop and they told me that the wheel was sticking, they suggested I change the caliper and hose, which I have, I also replaced the rotor and wheel bearings on both sides, after all this the thumping is still there, when I apply the brakes the car kinda shakes and as I come to a stop it feels like warped rotors but there brand new rotors, this is a rotational thumping, when the car is suspended in the air and you spin the wheel it spins three quarters of the way be fore it catches and you have to apply forces to make it spin again, passenger side wheel spins just fine, I have tried everything. Thank you for your time

My car has 257841 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Hello. You should try to remove the caliper or retract it and then see if you still have wheel binding. If it is binding with the brakes removed, then you have a wheel bearing or hub problem. If the problem does not go away when the brake caliper is removed then you have a warped rotor or bent hub. I have seen new rotors come out of the box warped. When this happens, you think you are fixing a problem when you end up creating one – frustrating! If you want a professional to help, a certified mechanic from YourMechanic can come to your home or office to inspect the noise and replace the bearings if necessary.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

What does it mean if the smart key warning light comes on?
If your car has a smart key system, then it’s equipped with a warning light and buzzer that help in certain situations when the electronic key might be missing or out of range. There are several light/buzzer combinations that might...
How do I use the conversation mirror?
The conversation mirror is part of the sunglasses holder, and can be used to view the passengers in the rear seats. To access the mirror, open the sunglasses holder, then press it back to the first detent.
Bad O2 sensor
Hello, code P0420 represents right main catalyst deterioration. There can be a few things that need to be checked before replacing parts. The intake system needs to be inspected for vacuum leaks and unmetered air leaks. The exhaust system should...
Change direction of wipers
This would require modifying the windshield wiper motor which could be costly. If it is an issue of the quality of the job they do, I would suggest purchasing better quality wiper blades.
Torque converter vibrates - 2005 Chevrolet Avalanche 2500
Torque convertor "shuddering" is a cycle where the torque convertor tries to lock up, can't, and re-cycles repeatedly. General Motors has a service bulletin - TSB Reference #3438A, that addresses this issue. Discuss this issue with your dealer.
My car is still dying out after replacing the alternator and battery
Remove the negative battery cable from the battery. Get a digital meter and check the voltage from the battery terminal and the battery cable without having the cable touching the terminal. If there is something on in the vehicle with...
Why does my '90 Chevy C1500 turn over but not start? I'm getting fuel and a spark.
Assuming the spark is adequate and fuel pressure is within specifications, an extremely worn out set of spark plugs (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/spark-plugs-replacement) may be the culprit. It could be a restricted exhaust system (i.e. a plugged catalytic converter) if you had a...
My car is jerking for an unknown reason
Hey there. This may be a sign of a failing transmission control module or low transmission fluid (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/transmission-fluid-service). The transmission control module (TCM) helps regulate fuel efficiency and power while storing information about the transmission system in its memory. A...
My alternator is overcharging to about 14.8-15 volts. Can that cause other warning lights to come on?
Hi. Yes, in a lot of cars when the battery is low or the charging system is malfunctioning, the ABS Light, Brake Light and the Traction Control Light will come on. This happens because these systems must have the correct...

Related articles

2011 Dodge Ram vs. 2011 Ford F-150: Which One Should I Buy?
Large trucks can be fun to drive, and even more fun to get dirty. Unfortunately, they may also cause you to get phone calls from friends who need to move into a new apartment. Fortunately, just having a truck may...
2012 Honda Civic vs. 2012 Ford Focus: Which One Should I Buy?
One of the best ways to cope with pain at the gas pump is to look at downsizing your vehicle, and today’s compact cars are a great option that allow you to keep the space that you need to move...
How to Buy a Classic Ford Vehicle
When it comes to American-made vintage vehicles, few brands are more collected than Fords. Indeed, many Ford models do embody the adage “things get better with age” – at least in terms of value. In most cases, once a Ford...