Q: Noise starting car

asked by on August 18, 2016

My car makes a strange bumping sound when I start it. Sometimes it won't make the noise. Then when I try again in 5 minutes it will make the same sound again. I took it to the repair shop, and they changed the starter and water pump, but I still have the same problem. So I took it to the dealership and they checked it with the computer and said it was my battery, so I got it replaced. The car ran good for a month. and then same problem started up again. The dealership can't figure out what it is. They called a day later and said they got a code from the chip in my key causing the trouble. Do you know if they are correct this time or could it be something else causing the problem?

I’m guessing the bumping noise you’re referring to means it clicks and then finally starts. Or possibly that it cranks and then starts? These are two different issues. A click no start indicates a problem in the starting system. A vehicle that cranks normally but doesn’t start indicates a lack of fuel or spark. These issues require two separate diagnostic processes. I suggest you get a second diagnosis of the noise from someplace other than the dealership. The team at YourMechanic is an excellent option since we make house calls.

Was this answer helpful?
The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing

Get a quote

What others are asking

Noise after the car is turned off, car idles rough - 1973 Nissan 240Z

Hello. It sounds like the starter relay might be bad and is causing the starter to stay on, which is the clicking noise that you are hearing. There could also be a problem with the starter solenoid. The problem you...

Car overheating due to nonworking fan

The fan on your vehicle is an electric fan. It comes on as needed to help cool the radiator when the coolant reaches a pre-determined temperature. This is usually around 220 degrees. Fan motor failure is common and not a...

Car making noises while driving

If your car is making a clunking or rumbling noise, I suspect that perhaps a wheel bearing or CV axle has failed. However, it would be hard to properly diagnose this issue without an in-person inspection. I would recommend having...

Related articles

How Long Does a Thermostatic Vacuum Sensor Last?
Winter Winter can make for tricky driving conditions - just starting up your vehicle can be a bit more of a chore. When the engine is cold, it takes a few minutes before it reaches optimal temperature and you should...
How Engine Timing Works
Your Your car engine consists of a number of rapidly moving parts, including a crankshaft, camshaft, pistons, engine valves, rods and pulleys. As the piston moves up and down, the valves move correspondingly, in and out. The crankshaft spins, and...
What Does "Twin-Cam" Mean?
Twin-cam engines use two camshafts to operate the intake and exhaust valves. DOHC engines often have better power and efficiency than SOHC engines.