Q: My catalytic converters need to be replaced

asked by on May 17, 2016

Ok, so my cats are bad. Would it be better to have an X pipe installed or just replace the cats? I'm military, therfore my truck is registered in Iowa. So I don't have to follow California regulations for smog or any of that stuff.

My car has 124755 miles.
My car has an automatic transmission.

Catalytic Converter Replacement $288.41 - $1959.69 Get a Quote

Hi there, thanks for writing in.

First of all, removing a catalytic converter is illegal in all 50 states. They are federal emissions items, and there is a very stiff fine for removing or tampering with them on a vehicle that will be operated on public roadways. Second, I understand that that because the truck is registered in Iowa, you don’t technically need to meet the California smog requirements, but you should certainly try to if possible. The environment is already in pretty rough shape, partially due to emissions from personal vehicles. The vehicle is also designed to operate properly with the catalytic converters. If you remove the cats completely, your car may not gain any power, and will set a check engine light due to the missing cats, which can put your truck in a reduced power limp mode. You would have to have a full custom exhaust built that is suited to optimize flow with no catalytic converter, then would have to have the engine control module retuned for a race only mode where the cat delete is built in. If you opted to do all this work, then your vehicle would be completely illegal for use on public roadways, and any shop that did the work could be subject to a stiff penalty as well. Third, if you ever try to sell the truck, it would need to be in one of the few states that has no emissions checks at all. Most states look for the presence of a catalytic converter, and without one the truck cannot be registered by the new buyer. So you would have to sell it back in Iowa.

My suggestion is to replace the cats with an OEM equivalent part or better, and if you want better sound or slightly better performance, opt for a nice cat back system for you truck. You can have a qualified professional, such as one from YourMechanic, come to your home or work and replace the catalytic converters for you.

The statements expressed above are only for informational purposes and should be independently verified. Please see our terms of service for more details

Get an instant quote for your car

Our certified mechanics come to you ・Backed by 12-month, 12,000-mile guarantee・Fair and transparent pricing


Experienced Mechanic?

Earn up to $70/hr

What others are asking

Check Engine and Service 4 Wheel Drive lights on.
Hi there. These issues that you are having would not be related to a tune up or oil change, though they should be done if they are over due. Since the check engine light is on you need to start...
ABS Light on
The illumination of the ABS Light indicates a problem in the system, and also shows that the system is temporarily disabled. The vehicle must be scanned through the OBD-II diagnostic port for the information related to the issue. A common...
Audi A3 Quattro Misfires while idling
Hello. If the misfire is only on that cylinder, then it may have a bad spark plug (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/spark-plugs-replacement) or ignition coil (https://www.yourmechanic.com/services/ignition-coil-replacement). The coils are a common failure on this vehicle. If the misfire is on multiple cylinders, then the...
how long can it take to change valve cover gaskets on 2003 Lincoln aviator 4.6litre
Hi there. The book time calls for approximately 3.5 hours to complete the replacement of both valve cover gaskets. But this will vary by mechanic, but this is the average book time. If you need to have them replaced, consider...
My truck wont start. I was driving it earlier and a big cloud of white smoke came out of the exhaust and it completely shut off
Hello and thank you for contacting YourMechanic. White cloud of smoke from the exhaust means that the engine coolant has gotten into the combustion chambers of the engine and is burning the coolant. This could be caused by a blown...
Power loss and black smoke from exhaust
Hi There, Black smoke coming from the exhaust is usually an indication of a rich fuel condition. When this happens, this can be the result of many things such as faulty fuel injectors, a failing mass air flow sensor or...
What should I do to fix if my car displayed "ac off due to high engine temp" on my 2012 Chevrolet Cruze
Hello. If this message is coming on then the computer is detecting that the engine is overheating. I would check the coolant level first. If it is low then there is a coolant loss issue. If the level is fine...
I have a 2009 expedition flex fuel 5.4l 3v with the VIN's 8th digit being a 5. Will a VIN's 8th digit being a V work?
If you are wanting to change out the engine block, then you can for there are no numbers on the engine blocks. The only thing is different is with the electronics on the engine that works with the fuel management...
Overheating, no leaks, replaced thermostat, fan clutch, radiator.
The water pump is a possibility although when water pumps fail they usually leak or make noise. It is more likely that there is a restriction of some kind in the cooling system. Since the radiator has been replaced, the...

Related articles

The Best Used Cars to Buy For a Graduation Gift
Your Your little bundle of joy has grown up and on the cusp of entering adulthood. Graduating is a milestone, and you want to reward their hard work and show how proud you are. Buying a used car is a...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You’re a Plumber
Plumbers Plumbers need to carry around all manner of tools and supplies. If you’re plumbing a large building, or even a decent sized home, you’re going to need a vehicle that has quite a bit of cargo capacity. A car...
The Best Used Cars to Buy If You're a General Contractor
If If you're a general contractor, you probably aren’t in the market for a used car. More likely, you’re looking for a pickup truck, because you need to haul equipment and supplies to various job sites. Most contractors will likely...